Eli Lilly CEO pushes back on Dario Amodei's medical claims

Noaidi 265 points 366 comments November 13, 2026
garymarcus.substack.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (20 comments)

903543958568

Says Gary Marcus, huh? Any statement from Nostradamus yet?

Arodex

Not only the CEO of Eli Lilly, but everyone with the most basic knowledge of medicine and health. Dario Amodei is in pure snake oil territory now.

coderatlarge

being close to someone with a rare terminal and slow-moving cancer that can take years and years to kill its host, i’ve been learning that even just testing whether a therapy is going the right way can take many years, so while i hope “magic happens” i have to concur that the statements being made ahead of a mega IPO seem a bit tragicocomical.

MichaelZuo

I doubt there is genuine belief in such claims. It would be a sign of some kind of mental derangement… so likely it’s cynical hyping beyond all realistic prospects.

Bender

Maybe there are people permitted to speak about science and medicine with Claude but any time I tried I would get my session [bio] locked. I take those discussions to Gemini that is perfectly willing to discuss epigenetics, supplements, peptides, cell reprogramming, safe sourcing of peptide API manufacturing, 503A/503B compounding, etc... What other LLM's are people using for such discussions, analysis, self diagnosis, etc...?

program_whiz

best points: drugs aren't limited by the ability to write code or do things on a computer. Maybe if we have fully embodied robots and fully automated assembly lines to generate organic compounds and test them with extremely realistic simulations it may help slightly (there is still the FDA and production barrier). Its just wildly unrealistic. AI has made good progress in text, code, math, digital images, and digital music. Basically troves of data that can be automated and trained on, validated, and with a purely digital interface. Outside of that, just gathering the data will be difficult, regulated, and sparse (that is if anyone will even give it to you now). While we can write a test to make sure we could generate drugs of the past, verifying we have generated any new working correct drugs is an RL loop with one iteration costing years and millions of dollars.

antiloper

Amodei sounds completely unhinged in that video.

dist-epoch

I want to be on the other side of Gary Marcus predictions. If he's selling (figuratively) Anthropic IPO, I want to buy it. Few persons were publicly as wrong about LLMs as he was.

bunderbunder

I remember when we were having more or less this same conversation about IBM’s Watson. It wasn’t even that long ago. The most interesting difference between then and now is that we didn’t have tech enthusiasts getting quite so invested in the conversation. Possibly because we were all familiar with IBM’s decades-long history of shipping overhyped and underwhelming products. Unfortunately we seem to have yet to realize that that’s a habit that’s endemic to the tech industry. Instead we still see it as thousands of isolated cases that, only by sheer dumb coincidence, happen to comprise the bulk of the tech industry.

ur-whale

According to Dario in the twitter video, AI will cure all human ailments. I wonder if AI will also cure psychopaths.

slibhb

It's no secret that people like Amodei think AI is going to become "superintelligent" and solve all of our problems (or kill us all). I don't think that will happen but there's nothing surprising about hearing it.

dirck-norman

It’s honestly offensive to those of us that have suffered for decades and have navigated a kafkesque nightmare of modern medical limits. Knowing how little Claude has “cured” software engineering, this is just garbage self-aggrandizement. Amodei seems to be yet another one of these founders who don’t know what they don’t know, but speak very loudly and proudly of their ignorance. One might even say he seems manic and unwell.

zero_23784

Everytime ai systems entered a domain, experts of that domain have been proven wrong. Biology will be similar. Here is the point, to be able drive huge improvements in a field, you do not need to know everything about that domain. Yes, biology is messy, but we already had incredible breakthroughs in this domain without understanding it 100%. Did we have the full picture when we created antibiotics, vaccines etc.? Maybe solving the big diseases do not require the amount of detail/experience people assume. Maybe we have/will have enough data to extrapolate and create solutions from imperfect knowledge.

wAdk129

Amodei does produce a cure: it is just called "snake oil" or "frontier snake oil".

menomatter

Not commenting on the crazy timeline but I ask: are these problems unsolvable by any intelligence however superior?

camillomiller

A deep and lasting reckoning is sorely needed. People like Amodei have to be brought back to reality by being confronted with the utter failure of their distorted view backed by deranged capital. I hope that this whole thing comes crashing down in flames like a fucking Zeppelin soon, so we can move forward to actually integrating these incredibly useful intelligence tools into where they can contribute to society and innovation, at a discount and without the CEO-enticing job-replacement hype.

cheapcheerful

Just to play devils avocado, Dario isn't Musk. He's got a doctorate in biophysics from Princeton, and postdoc scholar from Stanford Medicine. Curing disease seems to be why he got into AI, when his father became ill but died just a few years before his illness became easily curable.

jstummbillig

At some point I will have a LLM explain Gary Marcus to me. He seems just silly and incorrigible, and I am mystified as to why people I think are important think he is important.

233mhz

Browse https://www.reddit.com/r/accelerate/ for a bit and see how harmful these ideas are. Some people legit think there is no need to go to school, work, learn or care about anything because Musk, Amodei, Altman &co promise them "universal high income" and eternal life in 10 years...

lompad

Dario Bankman-Fried von Holmes? He's completely and utterly high on his own supply. That is what happens when you get told all day everyday how great your ideas are.

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
12,728 stories · 120,417 chunks indexed