Amodei Says AI Will Cure Cancer in a Decade. Doctors Are Skeptical

robin_reala 32 points 70 comments November 13, 2026
www.businessinsider.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (20 comments)

sandworm101

The actual quote is far worse than the title: >> In a 42-minute IPO roadshow video the company released on Tuesday, Amodei made the audacious prediction that "cancer, Alzheimer's, heart disease, mental illness — these will be relics of the past in, I think, less than a decade." Mental illness? I'm sure that will be worked out exactly a day after AI-induced psychosis stops being a thing. Question: Without heart disease, cancer and Alzheimer's, what will kill us? It cannot all be shark attacks and avalanches. What new horrible diseases will step up to be big killers in the future?

baggachipz

Fill that bag up to the brim before dumping it on public investors. Looks like everyone's adopting the Elon Prediction Model.

aqme28

Genuinely curious-- if we eliminate cancer, dementia, and heart disease, what exactly will there be left to die of in old age?

gensym

I've yet to see anyone with expertise in medical research express optimism that AI will cure major diseases like cancer in the next several years. Help us in parts of the research? Sure. But the bottlenecks to medical research are the speed at which the human body does things, and AI isn't going to move that. That also aligns with my (non-medical-expert) intuition. Dario et al are smart enough to know that as well, and they have not presented any compelling counterargument to the speed of biology, which makes me they that they are full of shit and know it.

tim-projects

Stock market goes up ”It's literally too dangerous for us to release" Stock market goes down "Ai will cure cancer everyone!"

vivzkestrel

wake me up when it can cure death

VBprogrammer

I wonder how Elizabeth Holmes is doing these days.

phillennium

Here's a more correct title: "One person (who doesn't know the future but has a financial incentive to promise golden age) promises golden age. Other people (who also don't know the future but don't want to lose their jobs) predict that they won't lose their jobs. Both sides can be utterly wrong, so we spend our time in vain here".

kashunstva

> cure cancer Which one? All of them? The mechanisms of neoplastic development and growth are protean. If his prediction is based on aspirations of finding a common pathway, I’m afraid it will be unrealized. I share his enthusiasm for assisted drug development and so forth; but let’s be realistic. Besides, doesn’t his company have an upcoming IPO? I guess it’s a fine time for unbridled optimism then, isn’t it?

fridder

This makes me very angry because it falls into the popular trope about cancer being a single thing to "cure".

ocius

I don't actually think that he's overselling that much. Of course there is no guarantee that all these illnesses will be fixed, but imagine how much more progress can be made if we set up one million automated wetlabs performing research on these sicknesses. I had an agent (irony) estimate that there are around 100k such labs around right now, and these labs are not used around the clock. So 1 Mio automated wetlabs count more like 3 Mio conventional wetlabs. If we now factor in that current models already have much better capabilities to access existing knowledge, and that they may in fact be(come) smarter than the average researcher, that factor increases.

shaolinspirit

Billionaires leveraging capital to live forever

FLeXMurphy

I really expected better arguments to be put forth by the community, however that hasn't really happened yet. Across the few HN threads this has popped up, the general stance is: "In other fields [coding, math] the experts said Amodei was wrong. He proved to be right. In this field experts are saying Amodei is wrong, therefore he will be proven to be right." That's as simple of a summary as I can given without getting into the details, which are irrelevant and devolve into nit-picking regarding specific wording used (can vs. will), who said and what was really said (or was not said), and so on. To me, that argument is not good enough. I would like to hear something a bit more step-by-step as to why people think he is right or wrong that's beyond mere "because he said so" takes.

unpleasurable

Full Self Cure

gnabgib

Related: Silicon Valley Promises AI Will Cure Disease. Drugmaker CEOs Aren't Buying It (98 points, 4 days ago, 131 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50415817

gavinh

Is "curing cancer" even well-defined? Aren't some cancers driven by bacterial infection? AI is going to cure all current and future causes of cancer?

qgin

It is very hard to appreciate what exponentials look like in reality. We're on track to have a GPT-3-to-Mythos sized jump in a single year in 2027 or 2028, and its not as if it's going to stop after that year. People have a hard time believing that's going to happen, so they don't believe we will soon "solve" robotics, and so they don't believe robotics can really run an entire biology lab, and so they don't believe we'll have industrical scale data-center sized labs running at high speed 24/7, and so they don't believe that the lab bottleneck can be broken.

ChrisArchitect

Related: Eli Lilly CEO pushes back on Dario Amodei's ludicrous medical claims https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50483480

cameldrv

IMO the problem now is that the human body is an extremely complex system and we only understand some aspects of it. The way we tend to make progress with drugs is to understand one or two aspects that are relevant to a disease, and then make a molecule that affects those, and then try it out. When we try it out though we very often are surprised that there is often some other regulatory system that nullifies the effect, or there is some other unintended consequence of the intervention, because we do not have a complete understanding of the system going in. The trying out part is what takes so much time and money, whether that’s in vitro, in animals, or in a human clinical trial. If we had a far better understanding of biology, we could predict much better what effects a certain molecule would have. Also, if we found a way to try things out much more quickly and cheaply, we could accelerate progress.

jakintosh

https://futurism.com/six-months-anthropic-coding I don’t really know what to believe anymore, nor do I feel like I have the time to think through what I should believe, but yesterday I was reflecting on how deeply crazy it sounded when Dario called “AI will write all code in 6 months” early last year. Granted, Opus 4.5 was released 8 months later and his “90% in 6 months, 100% in 1 year” ended up being more like “90% in 1 year, 100% in 18 months”, but it still feels crazy to look back on this claim from March 2025 and feel like it was an entirely different world. Does this translate to medical breakthroughs? I don’t know! I’m not a medical researcher. But I do know that using my software background in combination with AI allows me to do work with speed and rigor that was never possible before. Since I could not find a job as a software engineer in this market (even with a decade of experience), I pivoted into policy research and now work as a policy director at a pro-homes advocacy organization. The fact that I can build bespoke software to answer specific questions, or analyze specific data, or communicate a specific idea is transformational, and I feel like we’ve just scratched the surface of what’s possible. We have been able to do an incredible amount of very high impact work in a short amount of time, and I feel like my ability to leverage AI capability for this work is still on the exponential. Our capability as a very small team with a limited budget is genuinely expanded, just by looking at the projects that I can do on my own now with Claude and a week or two of my time, that would have instead been a $25k 6-month contract that we have to raise money for and hire out. Is policy research the same as medical research? Also no, and I know that trials add a significant lag, but I’m just not convinced that every other part of the process wont get faster, and that new capabilities to expedite research and analysis will make the time spent more productive. It doesn’t feel like a “sure thing”, but at this point, it feels like the riskier option to bet against the idea of “significant medical breakthroughs within a decade”.

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
12,728 stories · 120,417 chunks indexed