TikTok will not introduce end-to-end encryption, saying it makes users less safe

1659447091 98 points 63 comments March 04, 2026
www.bbc.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (18 comments)

maest

Do you feel safer knowing DMs are not encrypted?

sheept

I feel like this makes sense for a platform that targets teens. Plus, I wouldn't trust TikTok to implement E2E encryption properly—who knows what they've snuck into their client.

ronsor

Why would you use TikTok for private communications anyway? It's mostly a public short video sharing platform.

Bud

BBC calling encryption "controversial privacy tech" is deeply disappointing and dangerous.

ranyume

This might be off-topic but on-topic about child safety... but I'm surprised people are being myopic about age verification. Age verification should be banned, but people ignore that nowadays most widely used online services already ask for your age and act accordingly: twitter, youtube, google in general, any online marketplace. They already got so much data on their users and optimize their algorithms for those groups in an opaque way. So yeah, age verification should be taken down, as well as the datamining these companies do and the opaque tunning of their algorithms. It baffles me: people are concerned about their children's DMs but are not concerned about what companies serves them and what they do with their data.

xeckr

Brilliant. They're repackaging the argument governments have long made about E2EE being dangerous to children.

Tyrubias

TikTok’s stance against end-to-end encryption is unsurprising but still concerning. TikTok is a source of information on many topics, such as the genocide in Gaza, which traditional media underreport and many governments try to suppress. The network effect of big social media platforms means many people will likely talk about these topics in TikTok DMs. No matter what legal controls TikTok claims to enforce, there is no substitute for technological barriers for preventing invasions of privacy and government overreach. This is yet another example where corporations and governments sacrifice people’s autonomy and privacy in the name of security.

tw04

Reminder, Larry “citizens shouldn’t get any privacy” Ellison now owns tik tok. If you’re still using it or have friends and family using it you should stop immediately. It WILL eventually be used against you if this regime gets its way. https://digitaldemocracynow.org/2025/03/22/the-troubling-imp...

bas

Fascinating. What a time to be alive.

burnt-resistor

It's the Max app for Americans, now with 900% more US and IL government spying.

rdiddly

"The situation is made more complex because TikTok has long faced accusations that ties to the Chinese state may put users' data at risk." And yet, it's even more complex than that, since it's now owned by cronies of the current US President. I've never had a TikTok account, but conceptually I was mostly pretty okay with being spied-upon by China. I'm never going to China.

pothamk

The core tension here isn’t really about encryption itself, it’s about moderation models. Most large platforms rely heavily on server-side visibility for abuse detection, spam filtering, recommendation systems, and safety tooling. End-to-end encryption removes that visibility by design. Once a platform is built around centralized analysis of user content, adding strong E2EE later isn’t just a feature toggle — it conflicts with large parts of the existing architecture.

computerex

TikTok is a front for government surveillance, so it's not really surprising that this is their position.

blackqueeriroh

There is no way to do E2EE on a traditional social media platform with user-generated content and comply with existing US law. You can’t moderate an E2EE platform.

croes

> Grooming and harassment risks are very real in DMs [direct messages] so TikTok now can credibly argue that it's prioritising 'proactive safety' over 'privacy absolutism' which is a pretty powerful soundbite Means they read every message

matesz

Fun fact - there is a big correlation between World Wars and compulsory education. Of course governments and big corporations "care" about children. Of course!

Madmallard

clown emoji

dakolli

You guys haven't deleted TikTok yet. I don't use Zionist products.

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
3,471 stories · 32,344 chunks indexed