GitHub Is Down

DamonHD

First time that GitHub has ever been down for me (London, UK): 504 Gateway Time-out The server didn't respond in time.

yanhangyhy

shit i thought it was because my browser. sorry firefox.. why i am keep seeing github down news in HN?

rvz

Once again, GitHub is down. Last time an incident happened was 2 days ago [0]. Could not have happened on a worse day (Monday) and you can see how unreliable GitHub has been. Better of self-hosting. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48418183

forlorn

Ah, here we go again. A weekly (daily?) github is down thread

witx

Slophub is vibing strong

cyberjunkie

Waiting for someone to say this was always the case, not just post Microsoft's takeover.

Zealotux

Soon we'll have to track when Github is up.

Keyframe

What's going on with GitHub lately? I've never seen them having so much issues over the years as they do have now.

Rohunyyy

GitHub is down for like the nth time this week? Time for some truly ground breaking statements like this is the result of LLM (yes it is I know)

bob1029

This has gotten to a point where it doesn't really matter anymore. When a service crosses a certain reliability threshold it's like a phase change. The customer base eventually adapts to the situation. Anyone who still genuinely cares has moved to self hosted enterprise or something else by now. It was most tenuous for me when they almost met the SLA. Now that they've blown so far beyond it, the stress is mostly gone.

exploraz

> Following investigation, we are seeing that impact is limited to unauthenticated users when accessing Pull Requests or Issues. Our team continues to work towards mitigation with more updates to follow as we have them.

darkwater

Am I hallucinating or did they do a "cleanup" of the GH status in their status page? https://www.githubstatus.com/ API Requests with 4 nines of availability?? Issues with 99.96 uptime? PR with 99.61% uptime last 90 days?? https://mrshu.github.io/github-statuses/ marks PRs at 95.89% in the same period as an example.

ramon156

Welcome back everyone

JsonDemWitOster

The Google SRE book offers the following as one of the reasons to not gun for 100% reliability (emphasis added): > users typically don’t notice the difference between high reliability and extreme reliability in a service, because the user experience is dominated by less reliable components like the cellular network or the device they are working with . Put simply, a user on a 99% reliable smartphone cannot tell the difference between 99.99% and 99.999% service reliability! I've been on a shaky relationship with my ISP of late. What brought me to this thread today is that I couldn't push to Github. Notably this isn't covered by their downtime report so, going by the available facts, it's _probably_ not Github's fault I couldn't push; and I've just been on my daily stand-up call and I got disconnected so frequently. But looking beyond today's available facts, odds are there's a bigger problem GH is not mentioning in their status page. They say the current incident has to do with "unauthorized users" and I wonder if pushing a commit from my IDE client counts as an operation from an "unauthorized user" as I still have to authorize with my SSH key. It's just insane I can't decide which between Github or German o2 should be the more reliable service!

sscaryterry

Now self-hosting, left the dumpster fire.

deviation

We should have a pinned post, just for GitHub outages.

phplovesong

People seem to miss entirely that this is not (only) some slop code that makes github go down, but its the fact that they get 100x the number of requests since AI tools came to the devs daily workflow.