And yet, it moves
notfried
127 points
75 comments
November 20, 2026
Related Discussions
Found 5 related stories in 176.4ms across 13,334 title embeddings via pgvector HNSW
- 507 Mechanical Movements helloplanets · 540 pts · August 27, 2026 · 44% similar
- The Tower Keeps Rising cdrnsf · 419 pts · July 14, 2026 · 42% similar
- I Remain a Skeptic lproven · 101 pts · August 15, 2026 · 40% similar
- Move Slow and Fix Things (2024) ahmedhossamdev · 97 pts · October 23, 2026 · 40% similar
- Illustration Beyond Proof smilelamp · 52 pts · October 11, 2026 · 39% similar
Discussion Highlights (16 comments)
paulddraper
1. It is better to see the world as it is, than any other version. 2. Gratitude is profoundly the greatest key to a well-adjusted outlook.
aaron_m04
We don't have to resign ourselves to this. We can use every means in our power to stop "AI".
jason_oster
It is absolutely absurd to claim that AI proofs and discoveries are not human achievements. The artificial mind was designed by humans, and the machine that runs the mind was built by humans. It isn't alien technology or an insect hive mind that did these things. The achievement is so human it hurts. Invoking the Copernican principle in the same breath as lamenting the end of human achievement is ... I don't even have a word for it. Ignorant? The egocentrism is maddening.
fh973
And yet, a man can kill a lion.
jdw64
Maybe now we need to understand the world based on the things that move nonetheless. In fact, programming at the application layer isn’t fully understanding the low level internally either—it’s working by trusting the API, so to me it doesn’t seem particularly strange. In applications, when an API leaks, you look at the low level, but usually that rarely happens. You only need to look in when there’s an outage. The key point now is that clinging to formal verification like Lean/Coq is probably for the same reason. Maybe it works that way? After proving mathematics through Lean and formal verification, if a problem arises later, Lean and Coq find the wrong point again. To borrow Dijkstra’s words, a smart programmer knows the size of his own skull. In the end, I think what matters is recognizing your cognitive limits and finding the best you can do within them.
nater5000
>Instead, the mood feels mournful, or bittersweet at best. The proof came from an inscrutable silicon mind, not one of us. Maybe we could have solved this one ourselves, but instead we gave up and checked the answer at the back of the book. Yeah, just like how we gave up on trying to see into space with our own eyes and instead decided to rely on glass optics to see it for us. >Perhaps it’s beautiful and wondrous that the proof exists at all, but it’s not a crowning moment of human achievement. Right? Crazy how AI just popped into existence without any human input. Humanity certainly deserves 0 credit for creating the technology that can prove something that we, ourselves, haven't been able to. That's definitely not more incredible than just allowing math researchers to continue grinding away at this problem for decades until we've effectively brute forced the answer. Frankly, as someone who studied AI during my Masters, I take offense to the notion that the science that has gone into creating these LLMs is being treated like something that humans shouldn't take credit for. AI may literally become the most important technology we've created (even more so that the telescope!), and downplaying our contribution to its existence is beyond absurd. The author seems to care more about the "story" of these discoveries than the actual science itself, and I think they should probably stick to dramatizations and musicals that barely reflect reality rather than attempt to speak on subjects they don't understand.
zkmon
> There might still be time for more human discoveries, but the window is closing. Someday soon, any discovery we happen to make ourselves will be because no one bothered to pass the question off to a powerful machine mind. Human history for the past 3 or 4 millennia was built on some humans being more special than others - warriors, saviours, priests, sages, kings, thinkers, scientists, artists, writers, sports persons and so on. We celebrated achievement, success, art, thought, stories, strength, preaching, beauty etc. All this created motivation to excel at things, explore the unknowns, dominate other races, control resources, build tools etc. However all this will change forever. Human achievement will become unrecognisable, non-trustworthy. It will be a huge to recognise and reward human talent. Devoid of motivation to achieve anything, humans will become just the passive subjects with no contribution to society or nation.
MinimalAction
During the earlier days of AI boom in knowledge domains (say mid 2025), I had a sombre chat with friends. The gist was that I was feeling the existential crisis brought by the realization of how machines are going to leave no corner of independent inquiry to (average) humans. They all said, "well, life moves on one way or the other and people will be fine." That wasn't as comforting and to confront that reality in such short time is completely unexpected. It moves, but why does it not bring the same kinda joy?
edvardaksnes
Surprising that this is not Brecht’s Galileo interpretation, at least not as far as the wikipedia page mentions. Eppur si muove!
api
It’s only catastrophic if you pin your ego and sense of self to being special, or the dream you may one day be special. “I’m a temporarily embarrassed not yet recognized genius damn it!” If you’ve discovered the ultimate happiness hack of realizing that you need no permission to exist and that life has value simply because it is, it’s actually fun to watch. Imagine what we will get to learn. You’re not special anyway. None of us are. People also forget that science and even math have felt stuck for a long time. Physics feels stuck. Maybe we hit the limits of what un-augmented human brains can achieve. Maybe without AI the future was just stagnation.
WarcrimeActual
> It appears that Anthropic has just solved the Riemann Hypothesis, and I have Thoughts. So I’m going to start by telling you about a musical I saw last week. There might be great info here but I’ll never know. This kind of non sequitur manufactured quirkiness in writing is such a turn off to reading any further.
brhsagain
It's funny because the underlying sentiment behind the "and yet it moves" line is professing to be interested in truth for its own sake, and yet it turns out the real motivation is that these people get a lot of status from being good at truthseeking games. It's status games all the way down.
johnea
I have to wonder if human innovation is at an end, or if we're just seeing the transient rush of solutions as this new tech is brought to bear. Obviously, the LLM providing the proof of the Riemann Hypothesis is trained on every human effort to solving the problem over the last 150 years. Did the model prove the hypothesis? Or did it find an insight in previous work that was overlooked until now? What happens once all of the overlooked insights are brought to light? (like the flood of current CVE discoveries). Will the tech be able to proceed into previously unconsidered territory without the history of human effort, as training data, to mine for answers? I think we'll only know once we get there. I certainly don't think the question is already answered...
noisy_boy
We are not much but our minds. And we have made a not so great an abstraction of it. And now that it is doing things because we also have it scale beyond one human can muster, it is doing significant things. What else did we expect? This one isn't even anywhere as complex as the one we have been our ears. Wait till we use this one to make one better and use that to make one even better and so on. This is not even the most depressing line of the first paragraph of a totally depressing book.
terabytest
Even though I’m also feeling the somber mood, I’m not able to feel this change as a loss. Long term, it will probably lead to more discovery rather than less. The worry that I have, and I haven’t seen this talked about enough, is that humanity will stop understanding how things actually work. If we delegate all scientific work to the machine, we’re not incentivized to actually understand why things are the way they are. Those who spend their time intimately studying processes and phenomena will consequently be the ones that contribute the least to progress because their work will inherently be slower and limited by their own mind’s throughput. Losing our knowledge of how things work can be truly catastrophic and set us back heavily (or possibly end civilization) if for some reason AI stops working or goes out of our control.
jpitz
Ditch diggers do not lament a shovel. Astronauts cannot circle the world without reliance on a host of industries, machines, computers, and software they could barely enumerate much less replace. Why is this lever different?