An FBI agent called a Claude user about his chats

AustinLikesAI 28 points 24 comments November 19, 2026
austinpatrick.substack.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (9 comments)

barbariangrunge

Title needs renaming as per hn guidelines, no?

refulgentis

I’m doing legal work this week involving a school shooting case and a missed warning sign. Maybe that's why this doesn't feel like some quirky fun thought experiment to debate. The user knew he was trying to get a rise out of Claude. The person reviewing the chat saw someone saying he planned to kill his neighbors and had already called others to join him. Taking that seriously was reasonable.

cucumber3732842

I have no commentary on where we should draw the line when it comes to the chat provider narcing to the feds but can we all appreciate that this dude is gonna spend his whole life regretting that time the FBI asked him if he knew any Klansmen and he missed the chance to respond with "well they say the Klan is all feds, and now I know you" or some wisecrack like that.

kylecazar

"no easy answers here, it seems!" Speak to a model as if your words are being sent to a company that has warned you they will escalate to authorities. If you need to make threats and express violent thoughts get a notebook. And maybe a therapist.

breakwaterlabs

> but to my fellow Americans, when you’re speaking to the police about an issue, you’re under no obligation to speculate on answers. Youre under no obligation to answer them at all, particularly with no warrant, arrest, or attorney. > asks him to come down to the station for questioning. NAL: I do not believe your legal situation improves if you voluntarily agree to such a thing. “No, thank you”, can suffice.

bartleeanderson

This belongs on the same footing as Fuck your AI safeguards, but additionally Fuck Anthropic for adding to the police state.

curiousObject

Meanwhile in video games, millions of Americans, some of them quite young, are right now playing with imaginary scenarios of mass murder. But the FBI is not wasting its time visiting their homes, or blaming them for wasting the agency’s time. What’s the difference?

ultimafan

This seems to be the very definition of play stupid games, win stupid prizes. Never understood what people like this get out of pushing boundaries, it's a complete disconnect between reality in their head vs reality in society, sure you can technically be 100% legally right as far as letter of the law is concerned but that's not how normal people with emotions operate and sooner or later someone is going to end up getting hurt.

treebeard901

When you use AI, you're in a group chat with law enforcement, courts probably even doctors.

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
13,334 stories · 126,150 chunks indexed