Why did some Apollo missions carry a grenade launcher? (2019)

Skyfall106 238 points 148 comments November 15, 2026
space.stackexchange.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (18 comments)

akmarinov

> Due to an influx of joke comments, all joke comments on this post will be deleted. And then they wonder why the whole group is dying

wongarsu

Now I'm wondering how far a regular military grenade launcher could lauch grenades on the moon

vconnor

> They were part of an active seismic imaging experiment That is what we call plausible deniability. (Everyone complaining about this topic inviting jokes, and I’m the first to have posted one. Drama sells more than silly jokes these days.)

franky47

nasa employee: oh hey u guys are back early astronaut: moon's haunted nasa employee: what? astronaut: *loading a pistol and getting back on the rocket-ship* moon's haunted. https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/moons-haunted

throwawayffffas

The soviets did regularly carry a gun. For survival purposes, as they were landing in Siberia which has wolves and pretty big bears. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TP-82

fsloth

"The mortar package is activated by the "arm grenades" and "fire grenades" commands from Earth. The arm grenades command is applied to and gated through the command gating to the grenade arming circuitwhich charges the regulaz and sequential firing capacitors of the four grenades by applying a Z4-volt arming signal. A grenade arm pulse is also applied to the data handling function indicating receipt of the command." Page 2-170 (179 of the PDF) of reference [1]. [0] https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19710014816 [1] https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19710014816/downloads/19...

shevy-java

To gun down the aliens. The answer is so obvious.

dtgriscom

First thought: were these fragmentation grenades? Second though: nope: not useful for seismic research. Third though: on the moon, thrown fragmentation grenades wouldn't be safe for the thrower.

phendrenad2

Because the howitzer wouldn't fit?

stared

Doom 3 motto: "The UAC is making safer worlds through superior firepower."

m0llusk

Like it was just a default for the game engine they were using.

raffael_de

The question is pretty unnecessary given that it references the "ALSEP Flight System Familiarization Manual" [1] which also goes into detail about the purpose of the grenade launcher. 1: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19710014816

barbazoo

> We and our (263!!!) partners perform the following based on your settings: > Use precise geolocation data. Why does this site need to share my precise geolocation with 263 partners? It's madness.

fjd

Went down a rabbit hole to see if the Apollo "thumpers" were named so because of Dune. Apparently there were a few terrestrial thumpers in use by oil and gas surveyors prior to the book and missions... whomp whomp.

superkuh

Does anyone know why they had the grenade launcher? stackexchange decided a few false positives humans getting blocked was okay if they could mitigate the corporate bots and block most of them. The end result is that I can't read the page.

marshray

From November 2 to Nov 22 2018 the "DrSheldon" account asks exactly one question per day. https://space.stackexchange.com/users/drsheldon?tab=question... Like this one, most of the questions are worded to enable an easy answer from a primary source. In one instance the account answers its own question within the same minute: https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/31279/how-was-the-... In another instance, the account replies to a comment with "Nonetheless, this would be the question to document any examples."

eaf7e281

to show the moon people who's boss

alentred

From the comments: > Due to an influx of joke comments, all joke comments on this post will be deleted I think this is pretty much the story of late Stack Exchange.

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
12,728 stories · 120,417 chunks indexed