The avalanche that hit math is coming for AI development

crescit_eundo 61 points 101 comments November 13, 2026
www.dwarkesh.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (20 comments)

rsoto2

love reading about idiots that swallowed trumps "superintelligence" drivel. Altman said we had AGI years ago, now we wait for the "superintelligence"

quicklywilliam

TLDR; someone used some fake graphs and probabilities pulled out of thin air to justify an unwarranted conclusion based on a false analogy to a situation that is far from clear.

qw34ahg

The machine of AI influencers is running at overdrive. A true avalanche of bullshit.

mentalgear

It's coming for everyone: there's a startup that introduced robot arms that promise to learn anything 1 shot: if it holds - and there's little wiggle room for one shot - it would be a good indicator that manual labor is also soon gone. The only question that remains is if 99.9% of the world population will let themselves be fooled by UBI & VR to keep the 'masses content; while the 0.1% hold all the wealth and AI power. And this is decided now, because it is too late once AI is consolidated under one bi/tri-llionaire.

zaler

I feel like this is why more distributed control or open ownership of AI models is such an important goal for regulators. As AI accelerates its own development, the private companies that are initially maybe only a few months ahead of open-source will widen the gap more and more. It seems likely we end up with an even more extreme tech oligarchy than we already have when superintelligence arrives. And that's only if we manage to solve alignment and it doesn't do something more horrible.

orphereus

When is superdupermegaintelligence going to be announced?

dominotw

>majority of this acceleration today is likely attributable to Anthropic’s extensive use of AI to do R&D Lots of companies think they are reaping similar rewards from ai coding and research but it has failed to lift bottomlines or create any new products. My last two employers are gungho on ai and ppl have been producing unfathomable amount of ai output. To a causal observer it would look like we have really accelerated but this has had no visible impact on any of the products that employers produce other than make them shittier. Whats different about product development at athropic that ai is particular suited for not generating slop.

j2kun

What has this author done that would suggest we should listen to his opinion?

dyauspitr

Why is dwarkesh using the Trump term superintelligence. This is a bad look for him.

zarzavat

If AI is a verifiable domain, how do you get AIs to construct benchmarks to apply to themselves? It seems that the only benchmarks that could be automatically constructed are those for tasks that are themselves verifiable (theorem proving, coding, etc). Non-verifiable tasks require humans to define what exactly a good job is. The RSI hypothesis is dependent on an assumption that progress on verifiable tasks generalizes to non-verifiable tasks.

jazzyjackson

Hype hype hooray

iaanix

A lot of AI research can be already automated. The experimental part of work can be tonally outsourced to agents (at least for the topics that I am interested in). I had some success with outsourcing theoretical work as well. These days I use quite advanced orchestration. Interestingly, the most difficult part still is writing good stories for research papers. There I can still beat any AI. And when it comes to research we have been already covered by an avalanche of AI slop. There was always slop in AI research but now it is the fully automated slop. A few years ago there was some human-made slop, now it is being factory produced. AI can do good research on its own, but good research is rare in general.

aabajian

I think the next step for developers is to combine existing technologies. For example, in the medical imaging space that are thousands of published algorithms that were implemented once (by the researcher who published the paper), but never used. AI can now read the paper and one-shot an implementation. I do wonder if there are breakthroughs to be had by combining such algorithms.

afgfaa

Who sponsors this advertisement? Many AI boosters. https://sponsorradar.com/channels/dwarkeshpatel And that does not include Substack bulk subscriptions.

FLeXMurphy

At last, he's talking his book.

throw-away-mle

I work as a research engineer within an Alphabet company, and I have been in the industry for almost 15 years. I am in the same place as Dwarkesh. I have seen some things that have absolutely shocked me within the last two months. A team of agents rewriting a model from scratch that had had many years worth of R&D spent on it, beating the original in just a few days. An agent that anyone in the company can just message an experiment id and say 'improve this', and it will come back a few hours later with like 20 issues, having examined checkpoint weights and gradient steps. These agents know every paper, every trick, have amazing instincts, and can code up 20 ablations and start them running before you finish your commute. I'm finding guiding them is becoming less and less useful. I have never felt my obsolescence rushing towards me as much as now.

SirMaster

Why is there a limit from the chips? If AI is better than all the humans in every field, then it should also be able to design a better chip no problem. It should be able to figure out how to make new manufacturing processes etc to make chips smaller and faster and overall more capable.

root_axis

"The avalanche that hit math is coming for X" is already a tired meme. It's telling that the impressive success of applying LLMs to the entirely abstract domain of math is being used to make extrapolations about all kinds of domains that aren't amenable to 10k agents (intelligently) throwing shit at the wall.

lavendermon

What I find fascinating about AI predictions is the human nature reflected behind them. There seem to be two camps: the first includes the author of this essay, people who are beginning to believe that unknown capabilities yet to exist will soon become possible and are impossible to predict. This camp seems to be winning an increasing number of people due to previous unknowns being solved very rapidly. Therefore, belief has been increasing in this group that AGI and other big AI questions such as massive human job losses can't be far around the corner. On the other side of the spectrum we see people who still want evidence and kick their AI predictions out to a more distant future by pointing at current limitations. This group seems to move the goalposts as needed to support their argument with each new advancement. As the author of the article pointed out, he has moved from this camp to the first one. I have also moved to the first one.

Dzugaru

It's not only about verifiable or not. It's also about how high the fruit hangs vs how good your ladder (search heuristic) is. NP stuff is readily verifiable for example. Absolutely plausible that this math avalanche was 1 cm deep, and harder problems are not solvable without new math theories that have to be constructed with a lot of understanding needed and taste (human heuristic).

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
12,728 stories · 120,417 chunks indexed