The Atheist Bible

axiologist 28 points 60 comments November 15, 2026
suchanek.name · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (14 comments)

axiologist

»With more than 700 pages, 300 illustrations, 500 inspirational quotes, 1700 references, and 1500 cross-references, the Atheist Bible is one of the largest works on atheism, and, quite possibly, the largest monograph on the topic. The book is licensed by the author, Fabian M. Suchanek, under a Creative Commons Attribution license. See the legal conditions at the end of the book.«

silverFork

definition from chapter 1.. cut and paste: "A person rejects belief in the supernatural...This position is commonly known as atheism.... A person takes no specific stance towards the belief in the supernatural.. This point of view is commonly referred to as agnosticism.... The supernatural is anything existing outside the natural world... A god or deity is a supernatural being or spirit worshiped as having power over nature or the fate of humans... Religion is the worship of a god or the supernatural... The Dawkins Scale: Level 1: Strong theism. 100% probability God exists. ... Level 2: De facto theism. Very high probability God exists but short of 100%... Level 3: Leaning towards theism. Higher than 50% probability that God exists but not very high Level 4: Completely impartial. Exactly 50% probability that God exists.... Level 5: Leaning towards atheism. The probability of God’s existence is lower than 50% but not very low.... Level 6: De facto atheism. Very low probability that God exists, but short of zero. ... Level 7: Strong atheism. 100% probability God does not exist..... "" vel 4; and my mother at level 4 or 5 but at times 6 or 7..

graemep

It says it offers an atheist perspective, but surely there are many atheist perspectives. I would have thought that the perspectives of say Richard Dawkins, Mussolini, Mao and Bertrand Russell are very different?

manithree

Boring. I was hoping for something as exciting as the Atheist Hymnal. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xmwAD7nHqaY

zulux

I would expect an Athiest Bible not to appeal to gods. From the section about Truth: " Theories Persephone and the seasons As a motivating example for our study of truth, let us consider a story from ancient Greek mythology (inspired by a TED talk by British physicist David Deutsch1). To explain the seasons of summer and winter on Earth, the ancient Greeks had the following story: Hades, God of the Underworld, kidnaps Persephone, the Goddess of Spring, and negotiates a forced marriage contract, requiring her to return regularly, and lets her go. Each year, she is magically compelled to return to him. And when she does, her mother, Demeter, Goddess of the Earth, is sad, and makes it cold and barren. "

ehecatl42

> Chapter 17:Islam > Discusses the Muslim worldview. (For security reasons, this chapter is not available here. Ok, then.

ck2

isn't it weird that "bible" has a meaning of a fundamental reference book yet ironically is completely made-up often with incredibly few facts known at the time "knowledge" as a frozen snapshot in ancient history bending everything backwards to its naive reference point and it would be one thing if it was just harmless entertainment but instead used to manipulate and control all of civilization

MarcScott

As an atheist, I have an instinctive dislike of texts like this. I’m not sure what they’re for. I don’t need reassurance about my atheism, I’m not interested in converting theists, and I don’t feel any need to justify myself to them. I don’t identify as a New Atheist, though I enjoy much of their writing. Dawkins is a good author. Sagan and Hitchens were excellent. If someone wanted to explore atheism, those are the writers I’d recommend. Atheism isn’t a club you join. It doesn’t automatically give you a community or a shared outlook. I’m just as likely to like or dislike a fellow atheist as a theist. Atheism isn’t enough to make us part of the same ‘tribe’. Which is why atheism will never win the imaginary war some theists think we’re waging for people’s hearts and minds. Outside of a few New Atheists, we just don't care that much about what other people believe.

rdtsc

There are few atheist "churches" as well. I know someone who founded one. An interesting case was how they got into hot water with the local black community after they bought a bunch of "Maybe God Doesn't Exist?" ads and put them on buses that go through that community. They met with few church and community leaders and decided that maybe on that particular routes they shouldn't put those ads on.

eyehatewindows

"The Atheist's Bible: An Illustrious Collection of Irreverent Thoughts" by Joan Konner is much more humorous.

throw0101d

Given most the contents of Chapter 8, "Proofs", it would probably be better titled as "Evidence". There's only one place they actually mention a proof (in the 'technical' sense of the word), §8.7.4 "Ontological argument". Theologians/philosophers (even theists) have criticized Anselm's variant: > The lesson is not that Anselm’s argument is unsound so much as that it presupposes knowledge (i.e. of God’s essence) that we cannot have. Moreover, the idea that reason points us to the existence of that than which there can be nothing greater is something Aquinas himself endorses as long as it is developed in an a posteriori fashion, as it is in Aquinas’s Fourth Way. * https://edwardfeser.blogspot.com/2010/11/anselms-ontological... Of course in §9.1.2 we have this howler: > Science cannot (yet) explain what caused the Universe to come into existence. Adherents of the Abrahamic Religions argue as follows: Everything is caused by something. Therefore, the Universe must also have been caused by something, and this first cause of the Universe is God. "Everything is caused by something." No. Just no. For §9.2.2, "How do you explain the soul?", see perhaps: * https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/214350794-immortal-so... For §9.2.5, "Why should people behave morally?": > Fortunately, there is a rather simple explanation for why we should follow basic moral rules. Would you like to live in a lawless society where people can kill and plunder as they wish? Probably not. The majority of your compatriots think similarly. Therefore, the majority of your compatriots, as well as yourself, presumably, follow the moral rules of your society. That is all that is needed for the explanation of moral behavior. This is question beginning: they say "people should live morally" but do not say what it means for something to be moral. They should perhaps look into Alasdair MacIntyre's books After Virtue: A Study in Moral Theory and Whose Justice? Which Rationality? . If they want a system which is non-theistic, see perhaps MacIntyre's Dependent Rational Animals . More generally, Chapter 9 ("God of the Gaps") should perhaps be rewritten after better understanding the non-strawman variants of the cosmological argument: * https://edwardfeser.blogspot.com/2011/07/so-you-think-you-un... If they want to cover (logical) proofs, there should be sections discussing Aristotle, Plotinus, Leibniz (who starts at the Principle of Sufficient Reason), etc : * https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/35592365-five-proofs-of-... As well as perhaps Thomas Aquinas: * https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6963088-aquinas TL; DR: the author(s) of this work should perhaps go through the literature a bit more and write a bit less about straw men. (I've edited this post multiple times as I've worked/skimmed through document, and there are more errors (§5.2.3, §10.1.2) and gaps (§1.2.6) that I could mention to this already too long post.)

Animats

I'd suggest "Why I am not a Christian" (1927), by Bertrand Russell, instead. This is the logician's analysis of religion. A useful book today is "The Righteous Mind" (2025), subtitled "Why good people are divided by politics and religion". This is a psychologist's view of what value scales people run on, and how this interacts with religious belief. I'm not going to summarize. The author has a web site, but the book is better.

beAbU

Dunno, this has that familiar stink of someone trying to use dogma to control the thoughts of people. The same kind of people who invent certifications for agile software development, always spelling it with a capital 'A'.

Henchman21

As someone who once heavily identified as atheist, I find I can no longer even read things like this. I'm not on-board with religion either. What I've found is that defining yourself as being against something isn't particularly healthy or helpful in your day-to-day life. Perhaps I was doing atheism incorrectly or something. But for sure I was a happier person when I decided that I sure as hell didn't know what was going on so probably no one else did either and walked away from that part of my identity. Its nicer to be uncertain, I think. It certainly is easier!

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
12,728 stories · 120,417 chunks indexed