Socialism's Positive Rating Tops 40% for First Time

karakoram 65 points 99 comments September 23, 2026
news.gallup.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (14 comments)

yunwal

In my view, it's not that socialism with a lowercase s as defined by worker ownership of the means of production has gotten way more popular, it's that "Socialist" has shifted to mean New Deal Democrat as the Democratic party has shifted towards being the party of business interests. If you look at what Mamdani, arguably the face of American Socialism, is doing in NYC, it's basically deciding to hold businesses accountable for breaking laws and noticing where markets have failed to provide core needs in the city.

feverzsj

Retro socialism: "The public owns everything". Modern socialism: "You'll own nothing and be happy".

elar_verole

You gotta love that only 65% of the """leftist""" party's voters in the US have positive views on Socialism.

Varelion

Maybe we will see real change soon.

wronex

In Sweden we often think of our selves as socialist. I suspect it means something very different across the pond. Anyone care to elaborate on the differences?

RicoElectrico

USA is approximately the only developed country in which people consistently vote against their interest. For what it's worth, apart from the migrant scare, PiS, the far-right friends of Trump, made a comeback in Poland in 2016 by promising and delivering 500+ which was an unconditional payout for parents. And what Trump did give Americans? Half-assed tariffs which destroyed many businesses and individuals, and which were overturned anyway. Destruction of many jobs in the federal sector. Expensive fuel. And so on.

adverbly

/cries-because-georgism-is-the-GOAT-and-its-not-even-on-the-list

mig39

I live in Canada, where even our right-wing parties are in favour of public education and free health care. I guess that makes us all socialists.

anramon

It's late half of 19th century all over again.

4lx87

Define socialism. 79 percent of U.S. adults said Social Security benefits shouldn’t be reduced in any way according to Pew. 87 percent of Americans agree that Social Security should remain a priority for the nation no matter the state of budget deficits, according to NIRS. 66 percent believe the government should be responsible for ensuring Americans have health coverage (90 percent for Democrats and left-leaners), according to Pew.

maxglute

Plenty of democracy -> social democracy models to work from in last 60 years. This isn't feudal peasant -> babies first populous governance transition. Some of rich eating may happen, but blood of landlord refresh tree f socialism etc etc... sometimes you just slap the reset button when accumulation out of control

OhMeadhbh

As David Graeber once said: "The ultimate hidden truth of the world is that it is something that we make, and could just as easily make differently." I believe this, which I supposed makes me a Graeberite. Graeberian? Graeberista?

jauntywundrkind

When you have monsters like these, being as terrormongering as they are about socialism: how acn it not be popular? The attempt to make this a boogeyman by all the world's worst people, the most tormentuous demons is maybe not it's strongest recommendation, but certainly quite the visible one! A giant beacon in this dark night they themselves cast. In these demon's blanket national insecurity, this is their chief enemy? Their chief rallying cry, what they put themselves in opposition to? The only politics they talk? Must be something there!

GlibMonkeyDeath

The survey asked: "Just off the top of your head, would you say you have a positive or negative image of each of the following? (Small business, Free enterprise, Capitalism, Socialism, Big business)" So these terms are left as self-explanatory. In the US, "socialism" covers a huge amount of ground (from any government program at all, all the way to Soviet style communism.) So who knows what items people were picking. One thing that is interesting, look at the gender and age splits in the above link for "socialism" and "capitalism" - 15-20 point divide between genders overall, and I bet the split is even more stark among young people.

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
7,510 stories · 69,432 chunks indexed