Researchers detail over 1,500 verified cases of children with past-life memories

ajmagnifico 15 points 16 comments November 13, 2026
www.wbur.org · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (7 comments)

xvxvx

The trouble with this is that reincarnation is fully real BUT, the same ancient texts that detail it also state that you do not remember anything of your past lives. So this is a scam. No one ever claims to remember being an animal in a past life either. Ancient Indian culture has long been hijacked in the west for scams and other nonsense. Yoga. Meditation. Vegetarianism. Cults. It’s a shame.

sambeau

It appears that God uses a Malloc that doesn’t zero its data. Perhaps we are in a simulation after all.

jwibby

Sounds fraudulent to me. How would a three year old know the words "World War II"? IDK, maybe his or her parents taught him or her about it, but that seems unlikely. I am not coming at this from a dogmatic atheist standpoint; I actually kind of suspect reincarnation is real, but this sounds made up.

txrx0000

Interesting but highly dubious, and the conclusions are way too premature. Even if we assume the children truly have memories of people that lived in the past, that does not necessarily mean they reincarnated. It may be a hash-collision-esque process where two distinct entities accidentally share some information they're not supposed to, rather than past entities being continued. It also doesn't serve as evidence that we live in a simulation as someone else suggested in their comment because hash-collision-like phenomena may exist in base reality too.

nkmnz

> * I didn't come to this research with any sort of belief in reincarnation or anything. I was just curious. My co-authors and I do our best to be agnostic and faithful to data and what we observe...* This is exactly the problem. You cannot do science without an hypothesis to test. “Just looking at the data” will give you shitloads of false results because - by chance - data almost never looks random. You’ll always find patterns that you can interpret. Just close your eyes and look at the patterns in the darkness. Or watch the clouds on a sunny day. Or star at your woodchip wallpapers. THERE ARE FACES!!!

KellyCriterion

There is a large research project called AWARE 1 and AWARE 2: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37423492/ Their setup was a typical waterproof setup, placing signs in emergency rooms toptown on cabinets/lockers, trying to find out if there is something about the idea of "awareness" when people are on the stairs to death. Unfortunately, so far there werent any results. Another thing I read some time ago: Near Death Experiences seem to vary by culture - if this is true, then there is nothing "universal" down there, instead it proves that we are just concious animals for the short time we are living. If there is some type of "general/universal transcendency" to a "universal god", then why would esp. this "experience" differ by culture here on earth? So, my personal assumptions is more and more that the universe itself with its basic components is just some type of simulation and we are not aware of it since its beyond our limits of perception and meassurability. And we humans are just one of many species which came into existence by some coincidence/accident.

rurban

Does HN turn into an UFO and metaphysics site? Next one will find a scientific proof that the earth is flat after all.

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
12,728 stories · 120,417 chunks indexed