People Vote for Anti-Immigration Parties Because They Don't Like Immigration

barry-cotter 22 points 42 comments November 13, 2026
www.popularbydesign.org · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (9 comments)

fooker

Immigration implies change. Of course people don't like change. Consider though that we are all descendants of immigrants. How would you want your descendant immigrants to be treated?

Lucasoato

I think we can be more precise here: they don’t like massive, uncontrolled immigration of low-skilled workers. The most vulnerable part of the population fears that they might lose wages, because the low-skilled immigrants would do their same job for a lower salary. Nobody is against to highly trained, well-educated, rich immigrants (or nobody I’ve spoken to apparently).

regentbowerbird

The elephant in the room that this doesn't address is racism. In the West expressions of racism are illegal or at least strongly condemned, so we are left guessing as to how it factors in far-right vote. We can't rely on "what voters say" like the OP suggests, because for some of them what they want to say is forbidden so they say other things instead.

dudefeliciano

> Some people took that as proof that the voters’ real grievances lay elsewhere. The economist Tony Annett even put the AfD’s gains down to rising inequality, austerity and the loss of cheap Russian energy. I guess Texans are suddenly in favor of immigration, when 2 years ago they hated immigration.

eddythompson80

Not really sure what the point of the article is as it seems pretty dumb. The answer is simple; it’s the economy, stupid. People who are prospering don’t have much negative feelings about immigration or the homeless or drug addicts or any “them” in the “us vs them” dichotomy. People who are not are more anxious and stressed and feel uncertain about their own place. People in such condition have no capacity to welcome others they feel are competing with them on whatever little resources there is to share. It wasn’t long ago that people in cities villainized and hated rural migration into the cities within the same country. As wealth and prosperity increased in the cities those feelings dissipated.

atoav

I grew up in a rural Austrian village, where people overwhelmingly voted for 5he anti-immigration party. The only person with a darker skin many of these people ever got to know was the local pizza baker, a black man, who was loved by everybody for both his character and what he did for the community. There were other migrants but they weren't valued less. So when I asked people who voted for right wing candidates how they square the love for their migrant neighbors with their vote, the explaination typically was to point to foreigners somewhere in the bigger cities, but the ones living here are okay . When asked to specify which foreigners and what specific experiences they had made it always turned out that it was just a very vague thing and they haven't made any experience, but read/seen a thing or two in the media. They often couldn't even point to one specific article. I live in a city now and to this day I will sometimes see (clearly fascist) rural tourists in the subway, that are shocked and scared because they see slightly more people with darker skin tones than they are used to, despite no tangible bad behavior happening. A lot what motivates anti-immigrant people happens in their heads. And if you're rich that is good. Keep the people divided by skin color, otherwise they may start to think about the other divide.

zulux

It's ok to like your country and fellow citizens.

3000

who would have thought making the locals pay for non-integration would push the locals to the limits....

phs318u

Maybe. Maybe not. Racism and xenophobia have always been, and continue to be, a real thing for huge swathes of people in many parts of the world. If you scratch the surface of many far-right parties, behind the reasonable-sounding rhetoric you’ll find what many people really think. See the trove of AfD emails recently dumped for many examples of this. At that point I find it difficult to engage with someone in a good faith discussion when my very strong suspicion (extrapolating from extant evidence) is that they’re likely just bigots parroting smoothly engineered talking points. https://www.heistberlin.com/news/afd-leak-what-421-179-hacke...

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
12,728 stories · 120,417 chunks indexed