Parents pay $75k for Alpha's AI school. Half of its students missed math target

vrganj 63 points 61 comments November 15, 2026
fortune.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (16 comments)

spwa4

"Only 42% of Alpha students met the network’s goal of learning twice as fast in both math and reading, according to internal data first reported by The New York Times. The findings land as Alpha pushes into public schools, where districts are adopting its software in hopes of fitting more learning into less time." As someone who occasionally reads psychometric papers: WOW. That's an impressive result. That is equivalent to a very, very good teacher.

neya

A study of 26,811 secondary students in central China found that homework scores rose 18% after students adopted generative AI tools, while closed-book exam scores fell 20%. The OECD’s latest PISA results found that daily AI users scored lower in science than nonusers, while moderate users performed about the same. It's almost as if using AI only as a tool for execution rather than actual architectural decisions works out well. In HN universe this is the difference between an experienced architect using AI to write code vs a TikTok hipster to tell codex/claude to create an instagram clone for them so they can make a video about it "We dOn'T nEeD eNgiNeErs AnyMoRe"

TwelveEyes

What they hinted at about the school not actually sticking to the two hours per day of schooling is slightly concerning. I would frankly be happy with parity provided the kids only needed two hours of schooling per day, but if they aren’t committing to that then this is a bad result.

rodarmor

America's public schools spent $17,619 per student in 2024 and only three in ten students read proficiently.

inshard

So half failed to learn at double the pace, meaning more learned at a faster pace than benchmark. What was that number?

glpgeFwac

Expensive correspondence school that sounds like hell on earth, maybe OK if you're otherwise training for the Olympics. Why do parents sign their kids up for this? https://buildcognitiveresonance.substack.com/p/fourth-report...

jjcm

> the pitch is that students will “learn twice as much as their peers in two hours of academics a day” Given a standard school day has 6 hours of learning, what they're actually claiming is that their product will teach kids 6x as effectively as normal schooling. I do actually thing that AI-driven lessons are the future (I'd love to see a proper Young Lady's Illustrated Primer), but in my opinion the approach here is fundamentally flawed. The goal shouldn't be "less time spent learning", it should be to maximize the impact of the time spent. The time spent learning is education in its own, and minimizing it to two hours a day will only teach kids to search for shortcuts and reduce their resiliance. You can certainly go too far with this (imo a Kumon-style 8am-8pm 12 hour day of learning overloads kids and doesn't give them time for creative thinking), but I do think it's important to teach kids that dedicated time spent on a problem is valuable in its own right. Alpha's take is that this time is better spent on "real world" exercises and scenarios. From their site: > Whether it’s solving a 45-second pit stop challenge or exploring the breadth of global art styles, our workshops teach students how to navigate the real world with confidence. There is value in this iff the real world exercises are applications of the things they're learning. I was home schooled, and one of the most valuable things my parents did was give me things that were applications of what I was working on in my coursework. When I was learning geometry, one of my after school activities was calculating how much wood was needed for a deck that had a sine-wave curve and was made of 2x6 boards with a quarter inch gap. Once I did the calcs, we went to home depot, bought the wood, built the deck, and when I was a few boards short we talked through what I did wrong. It was a perfect way to reinforce how the geometry calculations could be applied. Alpha seems to focus more of their workshops on resiliance and leadership - ie can they bike all the way across the golden gate bridge, or can they do a ninja obstacle course ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Vo16UaJ26o&t=197s ). I don't see these activities reinforcing what the kids are learning that day, so I'm not surprised they're falling short of the claimed targets.

jareklupinski

> ... public schools can’t remove struggling students, the Times noted, and they lack the prize incentives Alpha uses at its private campuses. haha what how are they creating an effective benchmark when using prizes to incentivize children?

j45

This is a bit of a misleading headline. The school's target is 100% of students would learn twice as fast. They are finding only 43% of students are learning twice as fast.

Aurornis

> Only 42% of Alpha students met the network’s goal of learning twice as fast in both math and reading, > The core of the pitch is that students will “learn twice as much as their peers in two hours of academics a day” > About a fifth of Alpha’s private school students scored at or below the 50th percentile nationally in math last fall, and only 37% of that group met the network’s 2x growth goal by winter, the Times found. This article is trying really hard to make the results sound bad, but isn't this actually pretty incredible progress? Under any other circumstances, a teacher who doubled progress in math and reading for 42% of students would be hailed as a hero and studied intently. The headline of this article is trying to imply that the school is underperforming because, what, they set an extremely ambitious goal? And got 42% of students to meet that goal? I don't know what I'm reading here. We're supposed to be angry at this? This isn't convincing me to be an Alpha AI school fanboy. I have no doubt there is nuance in the details. But I'm blown away by how hard this article is trying to be negative, and how well it's working on readers who aren't thinking critically about these numbers.

themgt

About half of K-8 students at Alpha’s private campuses missed the goal of learning math twice as fast Research points to a learning penalty Professors have told Fortune that students who lean on AI summaries struggle with sustained reading. “Today, if you assign that amount of reading, they often don’t know what to do,” Timothy O’Malley, a theology professor at the University of Notre Dame, told Fortune‘s Preston Fore in June. “It’s not even an inability to critically think,” Jessica Hooten Wilson, a professor of great books and humanities at Pepperdine University, told Fortune. “It’s an inability to read sentences.” I love the meta-irony of this article being a fucking mess. "missed math target" one has to dig to find is "missed the goal of learning math twice as fast", and then the article goes on about how "a professor of great books and humanities at Pepperdine University" says students who use AI can't read sentences. The joke is Fortune assumes its readers also can't read sentences.

atleastoptimal

What's the point of paying the price that the best boarding schools charge for a program based on a tech whose core competitive advantage is being much cheaper than humans? Does every kid get their own H100?

vibebingo

https://archive.is/eTuxF

Balgair

ACX has much needed context for this thread: https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/your-review-alpha-school (2025) TLDR: Alpha school pays kids for grades. You do better, you get (relatively) expensive rewards. The whole article is worth reading, though, there is a lot of nuance. I've considered moving for Alpha and attending them, but in digging further (more than just the ACX article), we have opted out and gone wholly the opposite way into Waldorf education. The rat-race style and zero-sum thinking of things like Alpha, in the end, were real turn offs for us.

gregglain

The school I assume hit their financial targets. Well done.

opengrass

$75k for slop is bizzaro world. Even $15k gets you a school with smaller classes, teachers calling home and conservative rules on dress and behavior.

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
12,728 stories · 120,417 chunks indexed