Is there a 'right amount' of AI?

milali 36 points 63 comments November 13, 2026
coyotetracks.org · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (13 comments)

WillAdams

For awards, the use of A.I. should be baked into the category descriptions/rules of eligibility up-front, and the organizers should be free to have a contest which is AI-free (in terms of contestants, I'd like to hope bots would always be banned from voting), or a contest which allows it, or separate contest categories for use and non-use. For my part, I'm late to the game --- I used Google's LLM-enabled notebook to generate some sample DXF files early on, but I mostly hack away and copy-paste from Stackexchange and so forth --- flet.dev hitting 1.0 and offering an online studio did have me buying tokens and ultimately a subscription to make: https://studio.flet.dev/apps/bicQWc3Aul but for a long while it wasn't running and I was out of tokens, so I coded up: https://studio.flet.dev/apps/46tp8GPq9g while waiting for my next month of tokens to show up by copy-pasting and in a couple of instances asking Copilot about errors. Currently trying to work out how to get the previews in the first app to look right, maybe adding an optional toolpath preview to the latter, and how to get a larger and more complex version up-and-running with an architecture I can wrap my head around using a toolchain I feel comfortable with (rather than a browser app, my typical development chain is local driven by a .text file: https://github.com/WillAdams/gcodepreview using a Literate Programming system).

sobiolite

Reading stuff like this, I mentally recoil from the tone of self-righteous moral outrage. The ethical issues around AI don't seem any different than the rest of modern capitalism. But things like industrialised farming, manufacturing, fossil fuels, chemical production, etc. don't seem to generate anything close to the quasi-religious fervour that hating AI inspires in certain people. It's difficult to escape the conclusion that the difference is that the harm from those other industries mostly accrues to the poor and the working class, whereas AI is threatening the livelihoods of rich, educated westerners who thought their social status insulated them from economic shocks like this.

adamddev1

> LLMs, by definition, can’t make anything thoughtfully, because LLMs have no thoughts. ... apps that feel crafted, that show refinement, that feel intuitive—requires a human developer not only with taste, but with understanding. Well said, thank you. It saddens me that people can't understand this. Already there is the fallacy of "I can make apps with AI, therefore no one needs to code anymore," as if all coding was was making apps. But even the apps that people think are passable feel so fake, clunky and sludgy.

mexicocitinluez

What sort of ego leads a person who doesn't use these tools to write articles about their capabilities like this? > Anecdotal tales of discovering Claude has written four versions of the same function in different places, finding giant sections of code that never get called, and “bug-finding” agents that imagine and even create bugs are growing rampant. Growing rampant? As in their getting worse? Because that's not at all my experience. > The LLMs themselves don’t even “know” they’re working with code. lol What does this even mean? What does "know" mean in this context? Models identify the code, the language its written in, the domain you're targeting, etc.

hypfer

For wear reasons alone, I don't see myself typing stuff in full with the one set of hands I have, when I can also make the machine do it. RSI (Repetitive strain injury) is no joke in our profession. So that alone makes the moral 100% anti AI standpoint a bit weak and surprisingly ignorant, given that a lot of the anger is (rightfully) about ignorant tech bros bulldozing reality with slop.

SuperV1234

Human slop.

goda90

The amount that won't make me lose my job so I can keep providing for my family.

ionetan

I think different parts of systems carry different levels of risk. Some time ago I proposed a model for assessing the risk in a granular way. Putting a value (CCD - Cost of Cognitive Debt) on individual parts may foster healthy discussions within teams. Elaborating on it here: https://epiq.sh/blog/cost-of-cognitive-debt

bensyverson

Can we just fast-forward to the part where the moralistic hand wringing is over, and we all accept that this is a part of software development now? Were accountants this internally conflicted about the energy use of computers when they switched to spreadsheets?

chzblck

Way more than what this cat is looking for. Feel bad for people like this, seems like an incredible silly way to go about your life. separately there's something Ironic about believing that ai is soulless and not real while also being a furry.

t43562

We're in learning mode between the optimists and the pessimists about how much. I think it's easier to be an optimist and believe that no amount is too much - because if an AI is better than you at something...well... using it makes you more powerful. If there are subtleties that are wrong, you probably weren't in a position to realise what they were anyhow. If one can make money out of it and only the other guy will lose their job then ... so be it. Hence the optimists will push us all over the cliff as with many situations in the past - lets just build another coal fired power station or spray everything with DDT or use xrays to measure your foot size in the shops so you don't have to remove your shoes - and here's a nice round thing you can light on fire and breathe on to relax! We've done a lot of deadly things in the past before we've eventually learned at the cost of millions of lives. People got wealthy on it and we don't seem to have asked for our money back. The issue is whether the outcome is something that can be ignored or hidden - whether it affects a small enough number of people at once to cause everyone else to say "I'm alright jack." We have evolved responses in the past from unions to campaigns to stop smoking to netzero efforts but none of it was easy or quick and none of it is over either.

sham1

Heh, we really are reliving the same processes that prompted (pun not intended) the Luddites to smash textile machines 200 odd years ago. And looking at what happened with physical manufacturing of goods, the Luddites were completely correct about what would happen. See, the Luddites were not against technology, instead they were against the increasing social stratification that would happen due to the manner in which the machines were owned and operated. The textile machines were owned by a small elite of factory owners, who could use the new automation to produce textile in a more efficient manner than what could be achieved via a human artisan doing the same product. This was good for the factory owner as they could get the equivalent or greater output while hiring fewer people, leading to better margins. In some ways it turned out to be good for the consumer, as they could now get goods cheaper, and in many ways said goods would be at a more uniform quality, even if the quality itself might have been worse than what a master crafts(wo)man would have been able to produce. And that left the artisan, the worker, the producer. While many would have been able to pivot to using such machines or find other employment, many would have been left wayside after being made redundant by automation. And they, understandably, took offence to that, because they were deprived of a livelihood to support themselves and their families, which in turn lead to desperation, and as we know, desperate people can be very dangerous to those who they perceive as being the cause of their suffering. See the various strikes, revolutions etc. of the 19th and 20th centuries. Now, a common argument against applying the same logic to today and the use of AI is that AI would be coming for all mental labour, not just specific fields like software, but at least in my view, this misses the point. IMO the point is that the current batch of techbro oligarchs lack the decorum and taste to be the stewards of this technology. That instead of driving this technology such that it'd benefit all of humanity and try to help those who would become redundant by the machines taking jobs away, for example by lobbying for universal basic income or some other types of safety nets, the techbros gleefully tell the public and the boards of various companies how AI can be used to reduce the need for human resources and put people out of jobs as the machines automate the various industries, just as happened 200 years ago. They seem to revel in the fact that people are losing their jobs as a result of these things, and they seem to not have learnt anything from the Industrial Revolution. IMO every other discussion about things such as the quality of code produced by LLMs is frankly secondary to this argument of the ownership of LLMs being in the hands of a select few instead of the commons. The arguments here are just as relevant as they were back in 1848, just saying.

eviks

> I admit I have trouble reconciling “I don’t like using libraries I haven’t written” with “I love having robots write code for me”. (speculating) The easier way out is to understand that the first approach didn't make much sense either (even at face value "wanted to understand his code inside and out" can be easily solved by reading/testing the library code), so it's easy to get hyped up by another fad, there isn't much inconsistency between those at the deeper level of personal fascination

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
12,728 stories · 120,417 chunks indexed