International UN talks on controlling use of autonomous weapons collapse

nephihaha 41 points 24 comments November 21, 2026
www.theguardian.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (5 comments)

chank

This will never go anywhere anyways. It's one of those "despite common sentiment", we're going to do it anyways because the enemy is.

impossiblefork

So, my view is that this is going to be mandatory for increasing the range of drone strikes. Wars like the Ukraine-Russia war will therefore necessarily lead to long range drones that fly further than the distance they can be controlled, and therefore there is no militarily practical alternative. Problems that arise though, is that you can have incredible, worldwide oppression. Everyone agrees that it is sound to keep nuclear weapons out of other people's hands and it's easy to extend that logic to AI and drones too. So if you have this technology and others don't, then you might bomb them and their researchers to keep them down-- that's of course pre-emptive, but it's something we've tolerated in several cases, and although it might be against the UN charter, people do it. So one can easily end up with a situation where autonomous warfare technology is monopolized, and in that case since there's a persistent military advantage, it becomes appealing to use it to subjugate those countries too. If people have to deploy soldiers on the ground or expensive aircraft, there is at least some natural pushback. I don't see any solution at all though.

ZnerflBerp

Kinda hard to have meaningful discussions about this when the two biggest users and developers are at war with each other.

comrade1234

Ukraine, or at least some of the contractors they use, have admitted to using autonomous drones in testing on the battlefield in targeting vehicles. They seem to be ahead of Russia on it and the fact that Russia is objecting to restrictions brings up interesting questions.

rf15

Just keep building bigger and bigger nukes. What's with this unnecessarily complex middle step towards universal self-destruction? why build a rube-goldberg machine to shoot yourself in the foot?

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
13,334 stories · 126,150 chunks indexed