How Uber Protects Against Retry Storms

aftbit

I'd be interested to hear other strategies in this space. I've done the naive thing of allowing retries everywhere, and gotten into retry storms. When I was next presented with the problem, I tried the other naive thing of only allowing retries from the very top level service, which led me to redoing absolutely tons of work for each failure. What's a nice middle path that doesn't add too much complexity?

maxchisto

I'm suspicious of load shedding not mentioned in the article. Combine that with exp backoff in the caller and you got yourself a pretty robust starting point

whoevercares

Token bucket is all you need

prologic

So, effectively if A → B → C → D and D is failing, C may retry D, but B and A are discouraged from retrying the whole chain. This is quite slever. I also really like the concept of an "Error Budget", inspired by SRE and SLO(s) no doubt :)

Scoundreller

Meanwhile Google keeps giving me “please wait, do not reload page” walls, so I ctrl-r as rapidly as possible. Or is that the human test and response?

UltraSane

This feels like trying to reinvent Fibre Channel's flow control mechanism.

whatever1

Easy. Take a larger cut from the driver for each retry.