How Should Armies Fight?
ersinesen
38 points
80 comments
November 16, 2026
Related Discussions
Found 5 related stories in 330.0ms across 13,334 title embeddings via pgvector HNSW
- Why Arab armies don't win wars Tomte · 38 pts · September 17, 2026 · 60% similar
- The glass backbone: Why the Army's logistics will break in the next war baud147258 · 344 pts · July 09, 2026 · 52% similar
- War may be coming. Are we psychologically ready? meep_meep_meep · 45 pts · September 18, 2026 · 46% similar
- Silicon Valley is transforming the military-industrial complex? (2024) paimapi · 165 pts · September 10, 2026 · 46% similar
- US Army Created and Maintains a Fictional World for Training Purposes speckx · 14 pts · August 12, 2026 · 46% similar
Discussion Highlights (13 comments)
jareklupinski
in coliseums
spicyusername
Pretty horrific to consider
pjc50
See the "survivability onion": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivability The Ukranian war is stuck in a slightly dystopian equilibrium because neither side can afford to gain WW2-scale air superiority, or even Iraq-war levels of air superiority. The increase in use of cruise missiles by Ukranians against strategic oil infrastructure may be the only way of changing that.
walrus01
A fair bit of the modern era change (2022 and later) is: "Well, IEDs fly now..."
eth0up
Against those who would abuse their power
rdtsc
> The attacking Russians, who have no holes to sit in, no cities to shelter in, and can neither concentrate nor achieve surprise, are suffering astonishing losses But it still doesn’t bother them too much. Consider that they haven’t even started a full mobilization yet. They just keep sending groups of soldiers who then get droned, send another and so on. Eventually a few get through, so it’s a slowly advancing front.
jghn
How should armies fight? The leaders of both belligerents should be locked in a room and forced to settle things on their own.
elevation
You don't fight wars for the fun of fighting, you have tactical objectives. If your nation only survives the winter because of a supply of grain and heating oil, then any threat that cuts off those supplies will kill you eventually. Often economic solutions suffice, but if you must protect yourself by kinetic means, then the battlefield is determined by the location (and supply lines) of the threat.
Kuyawa
If I had nukes and you crossed over my border just once, I'd bomb your capital city into oblivion and get done with it I believe they are just using this war as a test for new weapons, there is no other reason to keep this going on for so long. War in Iraq showed us that full air power is enough to topple any government in less than a week, and that was more than two decades ago. Russia has the military power to erase Ukraine and Europe from the map and they haven't done it, what's their long run strategy?
kittikitti
An important war that's not included in this article is America and Israel's genocide against Palestine. I think Armies should not commit genocide and war crimes. I apologize if I offended you with this comment.
bluGill
Plenty of analysts have examined the WWII tactics Germany used so well at the start and concluded they were very very risky and just some minor changes to French tactics would have defeated them (but at a different cost - France would have had to abandon allies to get the troops in the right place, even though the war would have looked different we would be picking on the France for that dishonorable action today) That is the problem with history. We can see what worked and didn't work. We can't nearly as easially know what is luck and what is good strategy/tactics. Many commenters talk about the current war as if everything changes, but it is never clear what is a major change and what is a blip that works now but soon be countered.
Jamesbeam
Ideally, not at all. But here we are. One solution is to rotate all of the current political administration of a country to the frontline for the first three months of a war automatically. If they are too old to fight, they can take care of the wounded at the frontline or do other services, like logistics and cooking, but their life must be at risk at all times, just like the ones of the men and women they usually send into war, without participating in the meatgrinder themselves. Same goes for military leadership, it was dishonourable to stay back and command your troops for most of the time humans have fought wars. The current way needs to end, as it’s setting the wrong kind of incentive for military leadership, the same way it does for the political leadership. Since everyone can get elected, and being an elected representative does not require anyone to possess any special skills that no one else can provide, they can just be replaced with randomly drawn citizens during wartime. Every three months you rotate, the people who survived the frontline will automatically take a seat in the parliament for the next cycle, as they have the most incentive to end the war quickly, and the personal experience of every woman and every man who gets sent to the frontline afterwards. You need to give the politicians an incentive to choose peace over filling their pockets from a position of privilege. The only way to do that is have them experience war outside their patriot battery protected million dollar mansions and government buildings. Eisenkot is a good example. I doubt under him the future IDF campaigns will be run like the ones Netanyahu did, because Netanyahu and his family and friends were well protected and only concerned with building Gaza into a riviera, while Eisenkot had to sacrifice his children to protect the country. If it comes to actual combat between armies, the best strategy is to minimise civilian casualties and to create a scenario where you can operate freely against the enemy. This might rub many people the wrong way, but how Israel fought the Gaza war was incredibly effective because they didn’t need to care for Israeli civilians in the combat zone. Every bomb they dropped was dropped on the enemy, seen from a military perspective. If Ukraine had done evacuation orders at the start of the war and pushed for one big civilian evacuation while establishing defence positions, the war would be long over and Russia would have lost. If everything that moves beyond the first line of contact is the enemy, you can just go all-in. And that is what is necessary to end a war quickly and with minimized civilian loss of life. But we all know they would never pick that approach, because it’s easier to sacrifice other people than yourself in a time of war. Generals like Eisenkot, as many flaws as the man might have, are a rare breed. I could also name fifty marines who would jump on a grenade to protect you as a civilian immediately, but not a single US General. Wars today are fought by fat and lazy people from offices for profit, and unless we demand more from our political and military leaders, your legs will get blown off by a drone long before any of theirs. And the Putins and Trumps and even the Zelenskyys of this world are fine with that. But you shouldn’t.
amai
Tactics like the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghost_Army used ( see also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_dummy ) might also be used to confuse the sensors of the enemy.