GitHub Outage Tracker: Is GitHub Cooked?

johnea

Oh, I thought it said "Github Outrage Tracker". I was ready to click...

jakub_g

Possibly inspired by: https://red-squares.cian.lol/

arlattimore

I literally chuckled out loud when I saw the headline :D

kevmo

An important thing to consider is how much of their uptime without incidents is not the normal working hours. Their incident-free uptime on 9-5 EST, Mon-Fri, is probably like 60%.

bushbaba

could have been a page with a static 'Yes' and a significant portion of time it'd be accurate.

fenio

https://mrshu.github.io/github-statuses/

kashnote

I think we need to have a little more sympathy for GitHub. You could justify the jabs when we could all blame any outage on the migration to Azure, but then they shared numbers around the scale they're dealing with now that everyone is constantly building and pushing with AI. I think it's commendable that they're not limiting access to the site or (intentionally) throttling newcomers. Yes, they need to get this figured out, but a little sympathy goes a long way. I personally wish them the best and hope their on-call people can go back to getting normal amounts of sleep soon.

404mm

If backend GitHub services are anything like GHES then I’m surprised it even managed to scale this much.

rvz

They were cooked the moment they got acquired by Microsoft. This is why I foresaw that centralizing everything to GitHub was just generally a bad idea 6 years ago. [0] Now that there is no CEO of GitHub, there is no point to GitHub improving. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22867803

JeremyHerrman

> "GitHub has had 1125 incidents since February 2016, implying a monthly incident rate of 24" 1125 incidents / 126 months ≈ 8.9 incidents per month, not 24 still terrible, but why such an obvious error in the first sentence...

nightpool

Getting rid of Actions and Copilot and other secondary services almost halves Github's incident rate: https://i.imgur.com/XPcMIFr.png I'm a big fan of Github Actions and I think people are often a little too harsh on it, but it's clear that it's sad that it's come at such a high cost to the platform's stability

GrumpySciGuy

Yes, but I did not need to look at the tracker to know that.....

djieidj283

It’s ironic that the SCM that 2026 software engineers landed on, is one with a complicated distributed usage model and is slow/down because of a centralised service

Fuzzwah

Near the end of the 8.5 years that I worked at GitHub as an enterprise support engineer, I asked in an all hands if a "GitHub Classic" product had been considered. Much like World of Warcraft Classic, I imagined it would be a rewrite focused on matching the simpler feature set of the past. I was basically given the same response that blizzard gave that question; "you think you want that but you don't".

joshuahedlund

Given that the outages are caused by record traffic, so far they are only cooked in the Yogi Berra sense of “Nobody goes there anymore, it’s too crowded”

_heimdall

I feel for the team having to deal with these problems at github today. Its also beyond me how those in charge for years wouldn't have seen this coming. Github was bought by Microsoft, whether they wanted to acknowledge that internally or not. Microsoft went deep on LLMs, and specifically on LLMs for coding use cases. They must have recognized that LLM generated code and PRs would effectively DDoS GitHub. I can only assume they simply didn't care, likely driven by greed.

xyzzy_plugh

Is GitHub Cooked? Decidedly yes. Migrating to something else has been raised as a concern during every engagement with clients and prospective clients in the past year. "Do you use GitHub?" "Yes though we'd like to move to something else, we just don't know what yet." As soon as the next big thing shows up, they're done. And they know it.

devy

Didn't GitHub CTO Vladimir Fedorov just posted this a couple days ago? https://github.blog/news-insights/company-news/the-august-17...

imnes

It's not making headlines, but Google and Apple seem to be getting hammered by AI as well. Getting app updates approved to release on prod on Play Store / App store used to take days, now it's taking weeks.

tdg5

I’ve reached the point where I just feel a mourning kind of sadness for GitHub