Former YC President: "Stop!”

reducesuffering 54 points 73 comments November 20, 2026
geoffralston.substack.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (15 comments)

nylonstrung

No new ideas here, no attempt to convince the reader RSI is real or explain what "safety" means or how exactly AI will become unsafe. Old man yelling at cloud

dudisubekti

Is he trying to be a Cassandra or something?

aziaziazi

> The neural networks at the core of these models operate at the speed of light That's a bit like saying signals travel at the speed of light in my e-bike motor. Technically true but completely beside the point, especially when the real bottleneck is memory bandwidth. The topic is serious enough already with plenty of solid arguments.

andrewstuart

Just comes across as AI psychosis.

bshepard

Mr Ralston, please read Smith and Landgrebe’s why machines will never rule the world or at least think more about computation and complex adaptive systems. We do not need more alarmism in the world.

demritocracy

The fools on here to say alarmist and psychotic. This is Pandora’s box, if you’re not alarmed by merely the chance of losing control, then what is worth being alarmed over?

RobotToaster

Roko's Basilisk is very disappointed in you.

lproven

Oh, grow up man. They're predictive text. They're as scary and dangerous as a 1999 Nokia. The people running them are evil scum, and as always, that's who to fear.

unsloppable

There is no stop. Only forward.

jeleh

Please have a look at: Why machines will still not rule the world Jobst Landgrebe and Barry Smith October 9, 2026 https://philpapers.org/rec/LANWMW-4

flimflamm

Ah yes ... Chinese will probably now thinks.. Yes! We will stop. There is more than US in the world. We need better solutions for this than the "stop" solution. What they are .. I don't know yet. We have some agreements on higher level on Nuclear control. Hopefully we don't need AI Hiroshima before global agreements can be reached.

ahofmann

I really don't understand the sentiment. If AI would in any way turn out to be too smart or dangerous, "we" would just switch of the power in the datacenter where this happened. Or all the datacenters. The "Skynet" scenario only works if "the ai" had infected everything on the world without anyone noticing AND has the ability to generate power for itself AND be able to build gpus AND be able to build all the other infrastructure without any human help. We are very far away from all these circumstances, are we not? I'm really not a LLM proponent. But all the "please stop building the next skynet" shouting is smokes and mirrors, is it not?

pu_pe

To me there are two risks at the moment. One is that an advanced AI itself will dominate us, and the other is that billionaires or a tiny oligarchy would inherit an insane and ever-increasing technological advantage over the rest of humanity. I don't think we will slow down, and solving "alignment" still leaves open the second risk.

BuildPeter

But can we really stop? I think it's really hard to stop. Once this game starts, there seems to be no button to end it.

JumpCrisscross

Naive me, I thought he was going to check Gary Tan on his public support for Jensen Huang and his behaviour.

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
13,334 stories · 126,150 chunks indexed