First Strike

vinyl7 61 points 45 comments November 14, 2026
geohot.github.io · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (19 comments)

650

What’s stopping more electricity being generated in the US? It’s both financial and political, but private business could step up here?

dleeftink

The past few years, being either compute constrained or energy constrained has driven many innovations in this space. Either way, higher availability of resources does not always equate higher utilisation.

peter422

Of note, China has a population roughly 4x that of the US

PowerElectronix

How's the per capita energy looking? Still lower despite China being a manufacturing and industrial hub?

xgulfie

> Sell as many AI chips into China as possible, use the money to purchase solar panel and battery factories, and build out electricity capacity as quickly as possible. This... isn't how capitalism works. If nVidia or whoever sells chips the money doesn't just magically go into strategic infrastructure

p-e-w

> If trends continue, China will have 10x the electricity of the US in 10 years. And if trends had continued from 1900, our streets would be covered 200 feet high in horse droppings.

devy

Geohot, pierce through the noises as always, have the most brilliant thoughts.

nl

The future is unwritten. If the other front-age article on the Science publication about how human population will have overwhelmed the earth by now isn't enough warning, then I'm old enough to remember how the "Japanese economic miracle" was going to inevitably overwhelm the US. There is a serious lack of wisdom in lots of these statements. I like to remind people that multiple mainstream "AI Safety" campaigners have called for first strikes on Chinese data centers: In a new report titled “Superpowers and AGI,” former Obama-era national security official Jacob Stokes calls for United States to begin preparing readiness drills in response to Chinese AI development — up to and including military strikes on the nation’s data centers, the South China Morning Post reported. “Data centers can be bombed with conventional munitions,” Stokes writes. (He’s not the first thinker to suggest bombings to stop powerful AI; in 2023, AI critic Eliezer Yudkowsky suggested that countries needed to be ready to “destroy a rogue data center by airstrike.”) https://futurism.com/science-energy/obama-admin-official-sto... https://www.cnas.org/publications/reports/superpowers-and-ag...

noosphr

Solar panels don't run at night. Betting on batteries is betting on an exponential that's been growing at a third the speed it needs to for it to be meaningful. China's grid uses them to lower emissions during the day but has idle coal plants to keep the lights on definitely. This is something a capitalism country can't do. In short we need to build a five grids worth of nuclear power plants as a national security priority, the same way the interstate highway network was, if we want to have any chance of keeping up. In the mean time we can use gas turbines to make up the short fall for the next five years.

bigcat12345678

US people are kind of lunatically liberal in a few dimensions, like jaded person. Remember the extremely dismaying showings of political extremist behaviors? You don't need the AI chips money to fund solar expansion. Solar panels are already tariffed exuberantly. Removing that tariff, solar expansion will not be faster at all, because there will be another random political faction coming out to eat the profit. This country inherited a honorable tradition that is no longer fitting in this highly connected world. And few people are educated to objectively acknowledge that.

kelnos

What a weird take. China should be generating more electricity than the US, if only because they have 4x the number of people. And regardless, "generating electricity" is not automatically some sort of advantage. And I don't get his link to the X post that he's labeled "nationalizing nvidia"; what he links to is... not that. I agree in general that the US is completely mismanaging the adversarial relationship with China, but this post reads like a conspiracy theorist fever dream.

0x4e

That’s generation. What about usage? If they were at capacity, wouldn’t it be the same story?

redox99

Not trying to advance the Kardashev scale is silly. The US goal should be for the average middle class dude to have a 1000 humanoid robots to his name.

flemhans

Why would China need AI chips from the US?

xlayn

Geohot also says that AI will "address" the issue of how much we pay to humans vs how much energy they need... a.k.a. you should be paid just enough to eat and not die. "knowledge workers are so grossly overpaid compared to the energy they consume" https://geohot.github.io/blog/jekyll/update/2026/06/11/ai-wi...

airstrike

Now do it per capita https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/electricity-mix?tab=line&...

bob1029

If we want to beat china at energy ASAP the only real option is tremendous amounts of solar/batteries + large reciprocating engines. A lot more of this: https://www.wusf.org/economy-business/2025-05-06/lakeland-el... Reciprocating gas engines have very fast response times. This pairs well with the potential volatility of a large solar grid. You can get extremely good performance out of these machines with the blessing of turbochargers. They sound like gas turbines when they start loading up. Kind of like a poor man's version of the real deal. It's impressive how fast you can go from zero to several megawatts: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SzKu9QBGI4s . The engine is at a constant RPM that entire time. It's really bananas how much damage you can do with a powerful compressor.

dead_hn_theory

If the trends continue it will be much quicker than 10 years. They've already done a tremendous job in Africa which is a whole other thing unto itself. If they were to focus back on their own infra with all the skilled contractors they have, they can scale as quickly as they need to.

cobychapple

Selling China chips so US can afford China's solar factories… So basically a trade deficit with extra steps?

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
12,728 stories · 120,417 chunks indexed