Echoes (Live at Pompeii) (1972)

jruohonen 36 points 17 comments May 15, 2026
genius.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (11 comments)

jruohonen

Better than the Police, I am sure.

cassianoleal

I'm somewhat lost. Love Pink Floyd, but what exactly is being shared here?

nlehuen

This song is a wonderful >24 minutes psychedelic trip and reading lyrics on genius.com is missing out a lot You can listen & watch it on https://youtu.be/JQ2pTamaqQ4?is=T8TaqnsHRx0rqGyZ for instance.

harry8

That website is absolutely appalling on mobile.

ChrisMarshallNY

I loved that movie (worth a look-see if you're a Floyd fan). There's a bunch of studio sessions for Dark Side of the Moon in it. My favorite song in the movie: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hDoK1Hbk0SI

fuzzfactor

I always heard it differently. The echo of a distant tide By chance two separate causes meet And no one calls us to the void Proud within the day you fall Disclaimer - I remember the first US tour where they played this. It was not the first time I had seen them, and it was way before Dark Side of the Moon caught peoples' attention. Pink Floyd was still unheard of by most DJs everywhere. Echoes was on a vinyl album called Meddle that got very little airplay, along with their others. For about 5 years people kept telling me that nobody was ever going to listen to Pink Floyd or want to have them on the radio. Nobody believed me when I told them that cassettes were going to replace 8-tracks either :\ Years later after their hit records had flown off the charts and their concerts were packed, by the time of the Pompeii-featured movie, it was pretty much a final act of documentation about how they used to sound before they got popular. In the 1970's Quadraphonic touring feature film this video is from, the live Pompeii footage was juxtaposed with the studio footage from behind the scenes while they were crafting the Dark Side, which was in a typical way that would resemble what record companies were getting from other bands. Each musician often individually with headphones seriously and carefully perfecting the tracks that would be layered into the final product. In a relatively sterile and uninspiring environment by comparison to Pompeii. The contrast was quite intentional. Even without a crowd whatsoever they were having much more fun playing live and making this kind of recording, just like they used to do when their concerts were not crowded at all.

tingletech

When I was about 4 years old, this was the first movie I saw in a theater, it was a double feature with fantasia. Next time I remember going to a theater when my parents took me and a friend out of kindergarten to see Star Wars on opening day.

Projectiboga

I love this movie, but not the 1990's Director's Cut. They remastered it last year and gave it a new title. A newly restored version of Pink Floyd's Live at Pompeii, titled Pink Floyd at Pompeii – MCMLXXII, was released in 2025.

DaveZale

https://archive.org/details/pinkfloyd-live-at-pompeii-origin... for those not crazy about yt, no ads

ompogUe

Gratuitous Beastie Boys homage: "Gratitude" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZdJ5e70Q8mw

driggs

The Live at Pompeii "concert" in that empty amphitheatre has always felt to me like they were playing to an audience of ghosts or spirits. If you have the opportunity to see it on a big screen or IMAX, it's an incredibly moving experience.

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
8,303 stories · 78,303 chunks indexed