'Duffy Lied': Controllers Refute Transportation Secretary's Ground Stop Story
mikestew
152 points
44 comments
November 15, 2026
Related Discussions
Found 5 related stories in 134.0ms across 12,728 title embeddings via pgvector HNSW
- L3Harris statement on the Nov. 13 ground stop taspeotis · 85 pts · November 14, 2026 · 49% similar
- FAA begins retiring decades old floppy disks from air traffic control pseudolus · 89 pts · November 06, 2026 · 49% similar
- FAA issues nationwide ground stop due to "extraordinary circumstances" owenshen24 · 123 pts · November 13, 2026 · 47% similar
- FAA issues national ground stop – lifted 4.5 hours later zulln · 1460 pts · November 13, 2026 · 46% similar
- FAA imposes nationwide ground stop on all flights conn10mfan · 13 pts · November 13, 2026 · 45% similar
Discussion Highlights (14 comments)
schiffern
"Refute" makes it sound like there's juicy insider info, but it's just skepticism that FAA scheduled upgrades on a Friday daytime. This was a cascading multicast failure, which can take hours to build up. Earliest reports of disruptions came no later than 10:30 am, so it's quite possible the upgrades were performed in the overnight hours on Thursday.
alexpotato
Long time SRE/DevOps with 20 year of FinTech experience in banks/hedge funds/crypto and having seen many, many outages (some listed here [0]): - There is almost always a standard operating procedure (SOP) - Just b/c there is a SOP for releases etc, that doesn't mean that people always follow it - This can be due to many reasons e.g. laziness, being distracted, pressure from higher ups ("just push it out there and I'll take the risk" ha!), tired from having a newborn etc etc - Doing things outside the "green zone" deployment windows therefore always carries risk - All of this being said, EVEN IF you ARE following SOP, things still break in all kinds of weird ways - And the end user is not often the best observer nor do they have all of the context to determine what broke, how it broke and why. (There are exceptions to this though) 0 - https://x.com/alexpotato/status/1215876962809339904
jmclnx
Tin foil hat on: Microsoft Cloud issues ? aka Office 365 over the same period :)
LorenPechtel
Very good point on the timing. You do stuff like that at minimum load, not at maximum.
jml7c5
Asking air traffic controllers for their opinion on this is a bit odd — would they even know about networking equipment swaps? I would expect that to be handled by the engineers and technicians who work on the system, not the people who direct the planes.
xvxvx
Unless I’m just tired, the article, reporter and air traffic controllers are confused about hardware switches and routers having issues, and the act of switching out hardware. Duffy stated that the switches and routers were having issues and needed to be shut down. This seems to have been read as physical hardware switches, read ‘replacements’, were happening during the day.
sega_sai
I don't know what happened, but for me a red flag was the specific explanation given while the event was still ongoing: "overloaded router", followed by request for more money. If the cause was so simple , then it was unclear why it wasn't fixed immediately, so something does not quite add up (at least till an independent investigation)
nobodyandproud
Duffy is incompetent. This administration is incompetent. I’ve more scared to fly since 2025 when they started cutting deep, than the months and the year after 9/11.
noefingway
I don't believe anything that Sean Duffy or his ilk say. I would hope there is a detailed and accurate post-mortem published to explain exactly what happened. However, IMHO this is just another example of the destruction wrought by Trump/Musk/DOGE. I recommend reading this article by James Fallows: https://web.archive.org/web/20261114090809/https://www.nytim...
cmurf
Duffy is asserting everyone in this administration is permanently unaccountable and irresponsible. https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3n2ebpzqe3s27
j_not_j
In my observations, any time a politician issues some kind of technical excuse for why things screwed up, they are lying. Not because they know the difference, but because they can't understand the actual problem and managed to elicit some ELI5 explanation from people who actually do know. "Explain it like I'm a politician!" (cf The Expanse.)
ShinyLeftPad
> Duffy emphatically denied that the FAA’s recent nationwide rollout of an $875 million artificial intelligence system called Strategic Management of Airspace, Routes, and Trajectories (SMART) had anything to do with Friday’s disruption Anyone buying this? They announced countrywide rolling out of the system on Nov 10 so timing checks out.
howard941
An experienced systems engineer might have noticed the packet storm and aborted the upgrade in time to keep the fault from propagating. They all got DOGEd.
isolay
So they played around with AI and got burned. Shocker.