Dartmouth (Guarini) will not admit math PhD cohort this year
sebg
90 points
35 comments
November 14, 2026
Related Discussions
Found 5 related stories in 133.1ms across 12,728 title embeddings via pgvector HNSW
- University of Leicester to make redundant all pure math professors (2021) E-Reverance · 21 pts · October 17, 2026 · 45% similar
- Nearly 1 in 5 UC freshmen are flunking math, double the rate from 5 years ago bcaulfield · 17 pts · October 19, 2026 · 45% similar
- The Controversial Class That MIT Is Paying a Professor Not to Teach mikhael · 18 pts · October 11, 2026 · 44% similar
- No Country for Mediocre Mathematicians reasonableklout · 19 pts · August 30, 2026 · 43% similar
- Is mathematics about to enter the conservatory? _alternator_ · 27 pts · September 06, 2026 · 42% similar
Discussion Highlights (10 comments)
chrisaycock
> On Nov. 10, Colla wrote to current math graduate students that “status and support” for current students “are not changing” and that the program will see “every currently enrolled student through graduation,” according to an email obtained and reviewed by The Dartmouth. > “Stipends, insurance and the five-year funding guarantee all remain in place for students making satisfactory academic progress,” Colla wrote. “Advising relationships, qualifying exams, degree requirements and teaching and research appointments will continue as planned.”
cadamsdotcom
"The field is changing; rather than be a force for change or try to help steward folks through the change, we'll be sitting this one out. Good luck out there kids." Whoever makes these decisions should get admitted to the drama school!
fghorow
Also FTFA: """ Beilock announced at the meeting that the College is “working to reduce Dartmouth’s spending by $50 million,” in order to increase faculty and staff salaries “especially if and when inflation continues to rise,” according to a transcript of her speech published on the Office of the President’s website. """ Uh huh. Increase staff salaries. That'll fix things.
xhevahir
Everybody's attacking this but when have graduate school programs ever been responsive to the job market? They're constantly minting more PhDs, MBAs, and LLBs than the professions can absorb; even MDs have begun to find it hard to get a good return on their investments. Maybe getting out of that business is the responsible thing to do?
nswizzle31
As a Dartmouth alum, this is a step in the right direction. I appreciate that the school doesn’t chase growth for growth’s sake. And PhD graduates are being minted at too high of a rate according to many people.. so you’re damned if you do (“why aren’t schools preparing their students for jobs?”) and damned if you don’t (“look at them cutting positions!”). The reality is that a PhD means just about nothing these days. Speaking as someone with a PhD (very thankful I graduated before LLMs ruined academic publishing completely), I’d like to see a bit more meaning to the degree. Moreover, basically no one wants to stay in academia anymore because the pay is laughable and the prestige isn’t what it once was thanks to the last political decade. Salaries need to increase.
groos
It's easy to blame Dartmouth for its shortsightedness but they have a point. Education, including graduate school, is more and more resembling vocational training and anyone paying for it, whether an individual or the university via an assistantship program, has to calculate the return on investment. With the recent FUD created by LLMs for math research, it is reasonable to ask what kinds of careers math PhDs can now expect and whether the field can absorb the current level of math PhDs.
gwern
How large is this cohort or program in the first place? The article seems to be conspicuously lacking in numbers. And how successful is Dartmouth in math to begin with? If it's not in the top 10, maybe this is a quite rational decision post-mathpocalypse...
profsummergig
A law school insider at a top law school tells me that law schools are expected to start downsizing at some point in the future.
FrustratedMonky
Seems pre-mature. We'll still need PHds to verify AI. and to come up with practical applications.
pks016
We don't know if this is a correct decision for future or not. Event like this can start a domino effect in relation to current graduate students, other graduate programs etc. My issue with this is communication with current graduate and undergraduate students. If admins create uncertain environment, the trust, and quality of work goes down. As graduate students or even faculties have no say in these decisions, not sure how this decision was reached. (My guess) According to the admins, after 5 years there will be no jobs for Math PhDs, so they scrap the program. > She wrote in a Nov. 10 email to current graduate students that there “will be opportunities for students to participate in the review” and that she would meet with math graduate students and department faculty on Nov. 17. A little too late I would say. And all the meetings I had been part of for any issues (as a graduate student), the admins or faculties rarely listen to you as graduate students have no power.