Canadian Officers Don't Want to Serve in the U.S. Anymore

cisc 25 points 10 comments October 22, 2026
www.theatlantic.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (3 comments)

cf100clunk

http://archive.today/95dG5

icegreentea2

NORAD is unique - it is a joint command. The NORAD agreement requires the commander and deputy to from different countries (practically, it's always been a American commander and Canadian deputy). The agreement also requires integrated and binational staff. NORAD itself is responsible for aerospace warning, and aerospace control. It exercises aerospace control by having operational control (though not ownership) of national units. When the article talks about Canadian officers serving as deputy corps commanders, that's referring to Canadian participants in exchange programs. The US military has exchange programs which do 1:1 exchanges with allied forces. For example, a Canadian might end up as as a US deputy division or corps officer, and an American might end up as a Canadian brigade staff officer or deputy commander. The exchange programs are part of a broader American program to build military-military ties, increase interoperability, and maybe grant unique perspectives. NORAD spots must be filled, and will be filled. It just means that you're probably not getting the best or most motivated candidates anymore. The exchange slots will probably whittle away.

unsupp0rted

> anti-Canadian sentiment whipped up by Trump might make the country inhospitable It's not Americans who are being whipped up against Canadians, and it never has been. Are Americans "inhospitable" to Canadians now? Or more the reverse? Today tensions are highest, but even if Trump is the source, he's far from the cause. It's like the Mad Men scene where the junior blows up, enumerates to Don everything wrong with him and Don blandly reacts "I don't think about you at all"

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
10,306 stories · 97,141 chunks indexed