Can Universities Survive? AI vs. Higher Education [audio]

frereubu 30 points 38 comments November 18, 2026
www.ppfideas.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (9 comments)

yepyoukno

Let us focus on the transformation of individuals into competent capable and responsible persons. Universities have an opportunity to reinvent. The mind that there must be a currency conversion for every virtue is a product of successful western consumertopia. When we learn to live for ourselves rather than the measure of our projected whole we will learn in entirely new and more gratifying ways.

figers

Ronny Chieng Commencement speech clip https://www.instagram.com/reel/DfdEs7VhvaX/

chriskanan

I wrote an article about this a year ago: https://syntheticminds.substack.com/p/universities-must-embr... But as a professor, enrollments are way down. In general, this was expected but not prepared for just due to the "demographic cliff" due to people having fewer children in the USA. I think university leadership had an aspirational hope that foreign enrollment would fill that gap, but instead foreign applicants have gone way down (and this was starting to happen even before the Trump administration accelerated it). Universities are very slow moving and most professors, even in computer science, haven't really been using agents. Even as an AI professor, it is _so_ hard to keep up with the pace of change. I'd say my opinions are more dire now, than I express in that article I wrote a year ago.

thepryz

The problem as I see it, is the universities lost sight of what they were created to do and what their role in society should be. The focus seems to have been to meet graduation targets and generate revenue that could be redirected to research programs and maintain an academic ivory tower. Higher education needs to rethink how they teach and how they structure their programs so that going to college isn't a terminal event but a lifelong engagement. They currently fail to do that in a sustainable and scaleable way.

metalman

ZERO computer or wireless conectivity universitys. learn to learn,establish solid personal work habbits and organizational skills, and show usefull knowledge and skills in there chosen fields, then get clicky with it. we do not need hordes of 'google graduates' 'ai pro's', bro

bemtevi

I hope some of the existing ones don't, especially the top-tier research institutions. They're elitist, out-of-touch factories for producing cogs in the failing machine of AI-powered capitalism. Maybe something new and more human-oriented will come about that actually is kinder and more beneficial for the individual.

yepyoukno

I thought about this. Universities should be like monasteries (over time) where serious minded persons, either in the ascent as young minds, or re-investigating mature minds, go to test, and press the precipice of “modern” human understanding. A fresh look, or devotional niche will continue to churn human significance, whatever our technology does. Everyone else should just go make money, live well, and adapt (learn) on the fly.

mtrx

Since I run a writing-process-based AI detection platform (www.turingo.net), I’m in regular contact with many professors. Here’s what I’m seeing: Some have started banning AI and reverting to oral exams, and they say they’re happier for it! Others are trying to avoid AI by restructuring lessons around group work, in-class discussions, debates, and other activities. This takes a lot of work, and it’s unclear how it affects the quality of the education they provide. After all, you won’t learn how to write a business proposal through debates alone... Many feel like they’re fighting a losing battle against students’ overuse of AI. I’m happy to report that some of them are now my clients and use the writing process to TALK to students about their work. That seems to help more than making accusations without proof. There are also those who advocate for universities to embrace AI. The idea sounds appealing, but I’ve yet to see it implemented properly. IMO, they ignore that students need to develop foundational skills the hard way before they can tackle more complex problems or judge AI’s work. They can’t develop those skills by outsourcing the work to AI. It’s like claiming you understand a codebase just because you’ve done few code reviews... And with every new model release, it becomes harder to define what a complex, “AI-resistant” problem even looks like! Interestingly, I see the same assumption among students who want to be AI-ready for the workplace: that knowing how to prompt is enough... I wish I knew what the answer was. Maybe banning AI for the first couple of years... or entirely, as some professors already do? After all, isn't this how most of us learned? I’m certainly glad I’m not a university student right now.. :)

barbariangrunge

If you have teenage kids, what do you tell them to do to prepare for the near future? Do you send them to uni? To study what? Or do you advise something else? Curious how the hn crowd is approaching this with their own teenagers

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
13,334 stories · 126,150 chunks indexed