Caltech professor no longer grades homework's because everyone uses AI

ishanz 47 points 57 comments November 16, 2026
www.businessinsider.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (14 comments)

ishanz

https://archive.is/A5Nqp

my002

This isn't really new. Back when I did my undegrad (well before the AI days), it was pretty common to have math problem sets not be graded, especially in first-year classes.

SamBam

This seems fine, and I say this as a teacher that is struggling with what to do about AI. The course has an in person exam, which is graded. So the real point of homework is not to get a grade, it's too actually learn something. Perversely, by making homework graded you are probably increasing the number of students who feel they need to use AI to get good grades. Eliminating the grades means eliminating the fear of getting a bad grade, and so allows good students to actually use the homework to learn something. If they don't take advantage of that, well, that's on them.

WarmWash

What does the future look like? There are people reading the writing on the wall, people pretending not to see the writing on the wall, and because things are moving so fast, people who are unaware that anything has even been written on the wall.

sempron64

Homework should receive a nominal portion of the grade (~10%) to encourage students to do it and not be blindsided by course difficulty.

tygon

A key aspect here that the author says: They can use AI to do the homework, but unless they know the material, that does not help them pass the exams. Something like math will likely always have a requirement to demonstrate competency in something akin to a proctored exam. The dedicated students will want to learn. The ones that are not dedicated? Well, the AI does not help them much if the exam is weighted properly toward the grade.

jasonriddle

I'm in a graduate program, as a student teacher studying to become a high school math teacher. I have a mentor in the classroom, and basically, we only grade the homework for the completion, because we assume the students are going to cheat, so it's only worth 10% of their grade. Even with AI, and just grading for completion, some are still too lazy to do the homework. It's usually very clear who took the time to do the homework, because they either do well on the quizzes/tests or do poorly. So, it's not impossible. Just put less weight towards the homework, and more weight towards quizzes/tests/projects/etc.

ahsgqwr

So AI makes everything worse yet we still allow it. And academics are silent because they want funding from the perpetrators.

Silamoth

I’ve always thought the obsession with grading homework was weird. Homework is your chance to practice. It’s totally normal and expected that you’ll make mistakes - so why are students’ final grades being penalized because they made mistakes during practice? Don’t get me wrong, homework should still be marked for feedback. After all, that’s how you learn what you were doing wrong and prepare for an exam. But students shouldn’t be stressing over correctness in homework. If they do well on exams and projects, that should be sufficient to get a good grade. A student bombing the homework, learning from their mistakes, and doing well on the exam is a good outcome, not one we should punish by factoring homework correctness into a final course grade.

ramblurr

This article ended right as I started getting interested. What was I supposed to take away from it?

BeetleB

In my undergrad, almost all the math courses had no required HW. They'd assign it, but you wouldn't turn it in. You'd come to office hours for help on the HW, or ask in class (they'd often dedicate the first 10-15 minutes of each lecture to Q&A). It was awesome for people like me. No time wasted on neatly presented HWs. I'd do it quickly, verify the answers, and study for the exams. The flip side was there were many exams (you don't want your grade catered if you do poorly in one exam). A course like calculus could have 4-5 "midterms", and then the final. Often, they'd drop your lowest midterm score so you're allowed one bad day.

ActorNightly

Education in general needs to be redone. AI has highlighted the fact that education skips a lot of the fundamentals, often focusing on reciting things that you are supposed to memorize and not teaching how to reason for one self.

dragthor

How does the professor know again?

Kuyawa

Eliminate homework once and for all, it's worthless. Increase e-tests in the classroom, auto evaluated, showing results at the end, just like we do in online courses. Adapt to the new world. Make your life easier

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
13,334 stories · 126,150 chunks indexed