Artificial Intelligence Policy

thatjoeoverthr

You have to be jacked to use the jackhammer.

greensoap

University of Chicago's policy is more interesting: https://www.law.uchicago.edu/news/ai-strategy-statement

retrac

> AI use is prohibited for any use for any purpose in any exam situation. Read literally this bans the use of hearing aids in an oral examination. All the devices on the market today use noise reduction based on neural networks or transformers. Isn't that AI? (The manufacturers' ad copy certainly insists so.) Presumably not what they intended but "AI" is not defined in the document.

aabajian

Law is so ripe for replacement by AI. It is entirely based on established written arguments with gray areas, edge cases, linguistic subtleties, etc., being the crux upon which many controversial decisions are drawn. That is, law arguments are based on a mastery of language coupled with knowledge of legal precedent. LLMs are extremely good at linguistic reasoning and can be trained on ever legal case every published.

drenvuk

> AI can be used for research on papers ONLY for the limited purpose of identifying sources, such as cases, statutes, or secondary sources. Students are responsible for the accuracy of their research and all other aspects of their submitted work. Absolutely level-headed policy. Whoever came up with this deserves some serious praise.

treetalker

I’m curious how they draw the line for spelling and grammar checking. I’ve never seen a law school (or other graduate program) prohibit standard spell-checking or grammar-checking in software.

paulpauper

Banning Ai outside of the classroom is impossible, like telling students they cannot use google for take-home tests. Students will always find ways to circumvent these restrictions.

fnord77

> Future lawyers may need to use artificial intelligence (“AI”) fluently. But the current state of the technology requires that AI use be coupled with the cognitive skills necessary to strategically deploy the technology, to critically assess its work product, and to uphold ethical obligations to clients and to the legal system. So, not today, SlopSatan

jjwiseman

Earlier discussion of the University of Chicago Law School's policy: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49024980

ufocia

Most of this policy is unenforceable.