Are we just going to ignore that books are destroyed for AI?

nyxtom 55 points 61 comments November 13, 2026
www.forbes.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (13 comments)

nyxtom

I know this is old but it seems that we've somehow moved on from the fact that we're in a modern Alexandria moment where rare text is being destroyed

Lithuanian

Does it matter much? Books are digital anyway and every book has a copy of itself somewhere in the world. It's not like something irreplaceable is being destroyed.

pfdietz

Yes, we are, because it's a non-problem.

m4rtink

All books are sacred. Anyone who destroys books is a criminal and should be punished hard, ideally to make an example, preventing more books from being destroyed.

rc5150

what can anyone do individually to do anything about it? until regulation happens at a governmental level, there's not a whole ton the average joe schmoe can do about it.

Kim_Bruning

The better practice would have been to download an existing archive. They did. They got sued to pieces over it. So this is the only legal avenue.

vegnus

Is it true that examples of the books in question would be some operators manual for a 1970s toaster?

ChrisArchitect

Story from August OP; Various discussions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49330742 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49068738 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49310725 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49383026

khalic

This kind of clickbait headline driven, misinformed takes really need to stop, we didn’t get a single rare book title from these “reporters”, I wonder why?

genxy

This whole thread has brought the worst out in hn. Or maybe this is the mask off hn? Books are not a fungible commodity. Books are sacred, for them to be digested and shit out by a slop machine en masse as a powergrab against the future is grotesque.

throw1234567891

Yes. Stop beating a dead horse.

mannyv

AI is destroying my fetish objects! We must act and buy all the books to protect them!

BatchJob

A better question is if you are a bookstore owner why would you sell books to these companies? I wouldnt.

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
12,728 stories · 120,417 chunks indexed