AI tools are only as good as your judgment

ttt333

Is it just me or does this seem to be directly pasted out of an LLM

drooby

I can't tell if this is satire

yfw

The context this discussion seems to miss is the push to do more with less humans. Im not dictating the dev workflows. My bosses are. My judgment is as good as the amount of time i have to spend. Even if Im the best engineer, giving me a 2 min budget to review 10k lines wont go well. But it does not matter to my boss's okrs

Nevermark

The best way to improve your writing with AI isn't to have it write for you. Nor is it to have the AI clean up your writing. The best method is write, and when you hit a wall, or might even be done, ask the model "Do not rewrite this, but read it, step back and consider it as a whole, then tell me what strikes you, what works, what could use some work." Then create another draft. Repeat until neither you or the model see much to improve, or you don't consider the remaining model critiques convincing given your greater understanding of the context. Use the model's expertise to raise the bar on the quality of writing you do that day. And you will have raised the quality you expect and get from yourself going forward. If it is really important, then once you are convinced you are "done", have the model make a complete rewrite as it sees best. After all that writing, anything that improves at that point will pop, and you won't forget it. Any important task should be used to improve one's skills. With a model or without. That's the healthy frame of mind for using models.

raincole

It'd be a little more convincing if the article itself didn't read like something directly from LLM. But perhaps that's the author's point?

themafia

And you have a limited amount of bandwidth to expend on judgement every day. What, in the human experience, makes you believe you can maximize on this?

Mick-Jogger

My longstanding theory on AI is that taste will be the kingmaker. If everything is possible in a short amount of time. Having good taste and restraint will be the ultimate decider if other people will like what you're doing.

aussieguy1234

If you had a person using a frontier model with limited coding skills and a senior engineer using a local model, the senior engineer would likely produce better results, with less effort and faster.

Razengan

AI is like the One Ring: it only enhances the user's innate character. You could be Sauron or you could be Frodo, but most people (including AI detractors) are fucking Gollum.

emodendroket

The main insight here seems to be "treat AI as a junior developer" (not that it's necessarily bad advice but I've heard it a million times) and then the one actionable insight is asking the AI to argue against itself.

keyle

This post is straight up AI writing. Which shows really poor judgement... The problem isn't laziness — it's abdication. Wow. Whoever even posts these on HN should take a look in the mirror. Are you trolling?

dahuangf

The real risk isn't AI replacing judgment—it's people outsourcing their judgment to AI and forgetting they had any to begin with.