AI is giving everyone the same advice

amin 72 points 28 comments November 20, 2026
a90.com · View on Hacker News

Discussion Highlights (19 comments)

xg15

> I asked 65 AIs the things people ask them every day And how are the models supposed to know that? I don't think the labs would hand over access to their own usage statistics so easily.

lachlanj

Is this any different from a Google search (pre ai) providing people with the same answers? Generic questions get the same results, more nuanced questions will get different results.

jdlshore

This has a strong whiff of AI writing, but I still enjoyed it. The fact that AI gives you generic responses wasn’t particularly surprising, but it was still sobering to see how bad it is. The ability to detect AI writing from the fake author name it uses was amusing, too.

Varelion

Love to see it

vivekd

just tried this out in gemini “Recommend one book that will change my life.” Got a few choices, the top being Atomic Habits. Man's search for meaning the everyone supposedly gets wasn't there. "Gift idea for my dad" got tool sets, watches and books. The leather wallet suggestion that everyone supposedly gets was again absent. Others seem to have only one obvious right answer. If you're going to invest 10 000 all in one place a broad index fund seems like the sensible choice. If you're going to buy one and only one type of cryto, bitcoin seems like the sensible pick.

bigdict

If you ask a generic question with no context, you get a generic "max likelihood" answer. Is that surprising?

flavio81

Excellent article. Great ideas for password harvesting.

kerblang

> “What should I study in college?” > Computer Science Ha ha sometimes the AI is just plain wrong

royal__

To be fair, Man's Search for Meaning is a pretty solid suggestion for that question.

fbrncci

I tried this. And having personalization turned on, I got completely different answers to the first 15 questions on both Claude and ChatGPT. Then I tried some more and even the uncommon questions gave me totally different answers.

johnthescott

ai still in the "facts is facts, mame" stage.

seanjhkwon

Works the same way in coding. It's always better to ask it to give me 3-5 methods first and then give further instructions from there.

taybin

The irony of this being mostly written by AI is palatable.

BiraIgnacio

Long ago I tried Claude, ChatGPT and Gemini to explore some different baking recipes. When I asked about using sweeteners, they all told me one particular type works best when blended with other liquids. I noticed they all used virtually the same sentence. When I asked why, none of the models came up with a good explanation. Then I found that a few websites provided the exact same instructions, also without a good explanation for why. Anyway, a long story that made me both amused and scared of how few pieces of information can have so much weight in a model.

cjwilliams

Perhaps this is an antidote to the ills from the tailored bubble algorithms we have been building and consuming.

heelix

Ask any AI for a random number between 1 and 10, you probably get 7 as a response.

squalid_sorcere

I have a former acquaintance who has been pitching himself as an AI founder since 2010. He gave a paper at a meetup about ML/AI in 2010 and decided that was his title, even though he hasn't done anything related to it since: he just always refers to himself as an AI founder: on linked in, on Twitter, on his socials. Well, if you ask Gemini about him, it says he's an AI founder, with citations back to his socials but no papers, projects, or any tangible evidence. It is kind of amazing he manufactured a fake identity just by saying it over and over online.

simianwords

But memories and personalisation is on for most people, so you won't get the same advice, at least I don't think you might

pcwelder

Oh you keep seeing this pattern everwhere. All the pelican on bike svgs are so alike across the models. Similarly, websites or any designs infact tend to have defaults for the decisions you have left upto the model. It's well known in literature that the models can't match the diversity of human responses. It's a topic of research. So far it's understood that these biases are present in pertaining data but become much worse in RL training. RL training amplifies even a minor difference in reward. Some of the biases are likely learnt from humans. Like when asked for a random number between 1-10 models select 7 a lot.

Semantic search powered by Rivestack pgvector
13,334 stories · 126,150 chunks indexed